Jump to content

Talk:Joomla

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Former good article nomineeJoomla was a Engineering and technology good articles nominee, but did not meet the good article criteria at the time. There may be suggestions below for improving the article. Once these issues have been addressed, the article can be renominated. Editors may also seek a reassessment of the decision if they believe there was a mistake.
Article milestones
DateProcessResult
September 1, 2005Articles for deletionNo consensus
January 21, 2021Good article nomineeNot listed
Current status: Former good article nominee


supposed to be have been released

[edit]

My attempt to fix the word salad of "supposed to be have been released " by removing the superfluous words "have been" has been reverted. Can anyone suggest another way of fixing this article, or can we get consensus to restore my fix? ϢereSpielChequers 11:40, 5 March 2023 (UTC)Reply

Sozzled2904 (talk) 19:38, 5 March 2023 (UTC) Fair comment. The present perfect continuous tense in English is complicated for people for whom English is not their first language. I have changed the sentence from Originally, this version was supposed to be have been released in July 2012 ... to The original plan was to release this version in July 2012 .... The amended sentence states something that happened in the past, (i.e. the simple past tense).Reply

Suggest better reference for Joomla founders

[edit]

To describe the founder a reference (11) to the 10 years anniversary article from Brian Teenman is used on which no further names are mentioned.

The reference (12) from Andrew's post is IMHO more complete. I suggest to remove the reference to (11). Not sure if I can do so as my reputation here is not yet high enough.

Thx for considering AKempkens (talk) 09:39, 14 February 2024 (UTC)Reply

Awards and recognition

[edit]

The section relating to "Awards" — sourced entirely from https://docs.joomla.org/Special:MyLanguage/Joomla!_Awards — is impossible to verify as significantly reputable. These "awards" were the result of votes cast anonymously with no requirement that the voters were in any way involved with the companies who conducted these votes. The primary purpose of including these awards here on Wikipedia is not to attribute any merit to Joomla but, instead, to promote various companies such as CMS Critic, Packt and others that have no involvement with the Joomla project.

There is no dispute that Joomla is recognised in the open-source CMS market space (and a reference to the sources quoted by the Joomla marketing people appears above) but commentary that appears on various websites (such as the CMS Critic website) could be perceived as advertorial material submitted by software developers, or copied or plagiarised in order to manipulate market share; it is not possible to verify impartiality or an absence of bias by such authors. Material sourced from sites such as these needs to be weighed with a grain of salt; rather than including a disclaimer in the Joomla article about the reputability of awards or trophies, it is better to remove the table written by the Joomla marketing team from the article entirely.

Further, this "Awards" section does not appear on non-English translations of the Joomla Wiki page. Sozzled2904 (talk) 22:40, 14 April 2024 (UTC)Reply

"References to primary sources"

[edit]

While there may be more references to "primary sources" than to (say) independently researched commentary, this is because many so-called independent commentators have biases about the Joomla project. For the most part, although some primary sources may be interpreted as having a secondary purpose to lead readers to a more positively favoured opinion about the Joomla project, primary sources are quoted in the article where they support factual content. It cannot be helped that primary sources often contain opinion masquerading as fact; the purpose of the article is to provide as much fact as possible. I feel that the use of the phrase "relies excessively on primary sources" is not entirely justified; it is subjective and dismissive without providing a rationale as to why primary sources are unreliable.

There is not much reliable secondary source information available in this subject. Joomla is something of a "niche" product. I should like to see the warning advice relating to "primary sources"—appearing at the head of the article—to be removed. Sozzled2904 (talk) 07:35, 17 April 2024 (UTC)Reply

WP:PRIMARY has a couple considerations that should be raised when Wikipedia users are reading an article. As you mentioned, articles by the subject about itself will present inherent bias even when it is unintentional. You note that this is unfavorable in independently researched commentary, even though presumably they also contain factual information. However, relying on primary sources can also lead Wikipedia editors to interpret the information themselves, leading to violations of WP:NOR. Additionally, over-reliance on primary sources can be an indication that a subject is not actually notable enough to merit a Wikipedia article. Articles should meet WP:SIGCOV, and significant, reliable secondary coverage is valuable in assessing notability.
If the Joomla article was straight-up bad, it would likely be deleted. The WP:PRIMARY serves as an advance notice to readers of this article that it is not perfect and serves as an ask for editors to help improve the article. By adding the issue, this article also gets added to several categories that are regularly patrolled by users whose mission is to improve the quality and quantity of citations in Wikipedia articles (such as Category:Articles lacking reliable references from February 2024, Category:All articles lacking reliable references, Category:Articles needing additional references from April 2024, Category:All articles needing additional references, and Category:Articles with multiple maintenance issues).
I believe the tag should stand as it is accurate (albeit not nuanced) and beneficial information for both readers and editors.
Vegantics (talk) 14:10, 8 May 2024 (UTC)Reply

Improvements of history

[edit]

Hanna Plate (talk) 23:50, 1 June 2025 (UTC) Hello, I would like to suggest some improvements and before they're reverted, I would like to discuss it here:Reply

> The Joomla 4 project did not live up to developers' expectations

The biggest problem with Joomla! 4 was not the developers but that the "normal" users had to migrate (meaning they had to spend a lot of work on those activities). The claim is as hard to prove but, comparing the lost market share (e.g.: https://w3techs.com/technologies/history_overview/content_management/ms/y), I doubt that these numbers are all developers. Especially developers benefited from the more modern code architecture. End users suffered.

> work soon commenced on Joomla 5—released on 17 October 2023—in appearance, Joomla 4 with some of its legacy code removed.

The reason to work on Joomla! 5 that quickly after the release of 4 was the change of the release timing: https://www.joomla.org/announcements/release-news/5819-the-day-after-joomla-4-0-planning-the-future.html not any considerations regarding "disappointment of users"

> Joomla 5 uptake was slow (compared to previous releases) and user criticism further intensified.

Moving the people from 4 to 5 was much quicker (as there was less hassle) than moving from 3 to 4, so I don't think that this claim stands any verification. Especially if you listen to people using Joomla! the 5-update is praised, see: - https://forum.joomla.org/viewtopic.php?t=1012311 - https://forum.joomla.de/thread/21598-erfahrungsberichte-upgrade-joomla-4-auf-5/

> Joomla remained popular with its adherents but, as the continuing downward trend showed, confined to small niche market amongst hobbyists and SMBs, unsuited to large corporate use.

The reference here is an opinionated blog entry of User:Sozzled2904 not sure if this is a "proof" for "unsuited to large corporate use".

> A future version (Joomla 6) has been proposed.

Linked before, there is no "decision/proposition" to make another Joomla! version, there is a clear outline of: - every 6 month a minor version - every two years a major version This should be mentioned in the text, too.

Suggestion for a new text:

Following Mitchell's departure as President, OSM reorganised its board structure removing three of its director roles. The increasing use social media—especially for microblogging—impacted the uptake of CMS technology to build websites. The Joomla project also lost a significant part of its volunteer base as a result of an ageing population, continuing disillusionment about the future direction and a perceived absence of transparency about the board's activities.

On 17 August 2021, Joomla version 4.0 was released (some six years after work had begun). This was a major milestone release for the Joomla project. With the release the Joomla core team proposed a new release cycle with every 6 month a new minor and every two years a new major release [cite: https://www.joomla.org/announcements/release-news/5819-the-day-after-joomla-4-0-planning-the-future.html]

In April 2022 Abrahall commenced defamation action against OSM; the case ended in March 2023 with the plaintiff voluntarily withdrawing her lawsuit.

Joomla 4 brought some challenges in terms of updating from Joomla 3 and could not stop the decrease of market share over time. Many extension developer could not keep up with new requirements for updating their extension.

Joomla 5.0, released on 17th October 2023, focused mostly on a smoother update process and the removal of legacy code, while further updates implements secure updates [cite: https://www.joomla.org/announcements/release-news/5907-joomla-5-1-0-and-joomla-4-4-4-are-here.html] and at the end automated updates itself [cite: https://github.com/joomla/joomla-cms/pull/45143]. The update process was on the one hand criticized for the more restrictive minimum technical requirement on the other hand complimented for the easier migration [cite: https://forum.joomla.org/viewtopic.php?t=1012311].

Joomla remained popular with its adherents but, as the continuing downward trend showed, confined to small niche market amongst hobbyists and SMBs, seldom to large corporate use.

A future version (Joomla 6) is in development.

Proposed changes by Hanna Plate #1

[edit]
Sozzled2904 (talk) 09:57, 2 June 2025 (UTC) I agree with some of the points made in your suggestion but we must be cautious not to transform the article into an advertorial "puff-piece". The facts about J! 5's "slow uptake" may be the results of an ambitious release cycle by the CMS developers team, they may be the results of the CMS leap-frogging third-party extension developers, they may also be the consequences of a lack of documentation, they may be the result of poor communication (or marketing), they may be the consequences of a general trend to eshew CMS website construction, or it may also be that the J! community felt it was unnecessary. We don't know the specific reasons why J! 5 uptake was slower but it is a fact, nonetheless, that according to the market share metrics available at this time, the rate of adoption for J!5 has not been as fast as the rate of adoption for J! 4.Reply
Many websites—the majority of the estimated 750,000 websites that still use Joomla—are still based on J! 3. We do not have reliable estimates of how many J! 4 websites there are, or J! 5 websites for that matter, but there are more J! 3 websites still in existence than the combined sum of J! 4 and J! 5 websites.
I will consider the suggested changes to this section of the article and update my response in one week's time. Thank you for the effort you have made to contribute to the article's improvement.

Proposed changes by Hanna Plate #2

[edit]
Sozzled2904 (talk) 22:13, 4 June 2025 (UTC) Accepted the change of text concerning J! 6 "has been proposed" to "is in development with a release date proposed for October 2025".  DoneReply
I do not accept that the developers clearly communicated to the public that there would be a new major version release occurring at two-yearly intervals. I cannot find any reference that states clearly that all future major releases will occur at two-yearly intervals and to say otherwise would be speculative.
> Especially if you listen to people using Joomla! the 5-update is praised, see: - https://forum.joomla.org/viewtopic.php?t=1012311
The "praise" cited in your references is not supported by evidence. The Joomla! Forum has multiple topics where users complain about the obstacles impeding the adoption of Joomla 5 (not the least being the tighter restrictions w.r.t. minimum PHP and MySQL requirements and incompatible [third-party] extension software). Unless that situation changes, it is still reasonable to describe the uptake of J! 5 as slow for whatever reasons they may be.
It is axiomatic that all CMS products have suffered a downturn in popularity in recent times and Joomla is merely one example of the overall collateral damage.
> The reference here is an opinionated blog entry of Sozzled2904 not sure if this is a "proof" for "unsuited to large corporate use".
While it can be argued that the article you refer to is a matter of opinion, by the same token that article also makes numerous references to other articles that do not support the contention that J! 5 is suited to large corporate website usage. The article does not prove one thing or another; it is an article offering research—further reading, if you like—about what exists and the reference is simply a footnote to the Wikipedia article on Joomla.
Hanna Plate (talk) 23:30, 4 June 2025 (UTC) Looks really official/clear for me with the release cycle: https://manual.joomla.org/docs/development-strategy/software-release-cycle/Reply
And for "not suited for large corporate", just some quick search:
https://w3techs.com/sites/info/lawinsport.com
https://w3techs.com/sites/info/securedbydesign.com
Not sure if top 10m in popularity + police from London + big lawyer page are examples for big pages? Or what does it need to "proof", that this absolute statement is not correct?
Sozzled2904 (talk) 13:13, 5 June 2025 (UTC) Thank you for providing a reference about the policy announcement that new major releases would occur at two-yearly intervals even if those major releases do not substantially enhance or diminish the core CMS product. I accept the information and it is worth incorporating this citation in the main article.  DoneReply
Thank you for updating the text.
Hanna Plate (talk) 09:13, 5 June 2025 (UTC) I think (not sure if this is relevant, though) that the date is not completely correct. I remember, that in 2022 there was already a big discussion about the new major coming every 2 years (https://github.com/joomla/joomla-cms/discussions/38407). I can't find any article earlier than https://www.joomla.org/announcements/release-news/5863-joomla-5-0-bold-in-one-year-but-can-we-do-it.html for the reference. I remember vaguely that I heard the first time somewhere around Joomla 4.1, but I'm not sure where, so 2022 could be earliest? Looking into the web archive the "every 6 months a minor" was there before 2020: https://web.archive.org/web/20200810061337/https://developer.joomla.org/development-strategy.html but again not sure what to make out of it?Reply
Thank you again for the discussion, learnt a lot!
Sozzled2904 (talk) 22:17, 5 June 2025 (UTC) It's possible that a decision to release a major version of Joomla every two years happened before April 2025 but, as you say, it's unfortunate that there's no publicly available reference establishing when this took place. New releases of Joomla occur as they occur and as the remaining handful of developers have time available to to construct and test them. The Wikipedia article relies on being able to cite references to support the facts.Reply
The purpose of the Talk page is to suggest ways of improving the quality of the article but not to debate the content, per se. If the sticking point is the use of the words "[Joomla 5] is unsuited to large corporate use" and if the words imply a negative bias then it will be difficult to find a neutral way of saying that the developers' main objectives (i.e. that J! 5 would be adopted in large corporate use) were realised. I am sure there we can find examples of J! 5 websites on the internet. The article does not say that J! 5 is unsuitable for large corporate use; that would imply that there are technical issues that prevent J! 5 being used in large corporate websites. The article simply states that Joomla is unsuited to large corporate use meaning that, in general, Joomla does not meet the operational needs of those businesses. The difference is subtly nuanced—and well understood by native English speakers—but should not be taken as biased or negatively critical. There is little available evidence about Joomla being used in large corporate websites. Citing one or two examples does not significantly alter the conclusions; the conclusion being that J! 5 did not meet one of the key goals goals, viz. that corporations would change their internet presence and adopt the J! CMS.


References

Update to History: 2025–present

[edit]

Disclosure: I am currently the Outreach Department Coordinator for Open Source Matters/Joomla and therefore have a conflict of interest regarding this article. I am proposing the following update for review rather than editing the article directly.

The current 2025–present history ends with the OSM governance events of late 2025. I would like to propose extending the section to cover significant subsequent developments during 2026, including restoration of the OSM board, implementation of the project's published product strategy, the Joomla 6.1 release and the accessibility programme supported by Germany's Sovereign Tech Agency/Sovereign Tech Fund.

During 2026, Open Source Matters re-established a full board of directors and development of Joomla continued under a product strategy developed during a Production Department sprint in September 2025. The strategy established priorities including accessibility and security, improved interoperability with artificial intelligence tools, and simplifying the onboarding experience for new users.{{cite web |url=https://developer.joomla.org/strategy.html |title=Joomla Product Strategy |website=Joomla! Developer Network |publisher=Open Source Matters |access-date=15 September 2026}}

Joomla 6.1 was released on 14 April 2026,{{cite web |url=https://www.joomla.org/announcements/release-news/joomla-6-1-is-here.html |title=Joomla 6.1 is here! |website=Joomla.org |date=14 April 2026 |access-date=15 September 2026}} with development of the 6.x series continuing alongside work towards subsequent major versions.{{cite web |url=https://developer.joomla.org/roadmap |title=Joomla! Project Roadmap |website=Joomla! Developer Network |access-date=15 September 2026}}

In 2026, Germany's Sovereign Tech Agency began funding a programme to improve Joomla's accessibility.{{cite web |url=https://www.sovereign.tech/tech |title=Technologies and Projects |website=Sovereign Tech Agency |access-date=15 September 2026}} Open Source Matters described the investment as supporting a 20-month programme aimed at improving conformance with WCAG 2.2, including independent accessibility auditing, improvements to Joomla's design system and administration interfaces, automated testing and developer documentation.{{cite web |url=https://www.joomla.org/media-press/sovereign-tech-fund.html |title=Sovereign Tech Fund |website=Joomla.org |publisher=Open Source Matters |date=July 2026 |access-date=15 September 2026}} Pixelhaus (talk) 14:54, 15 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

Biographies of Living Persons: incorrect claims about bankruptcy and lawsuit outcome

[edit]

Hello. I am the subject of this article (Abrahall). Two statements are factually incorrect and should be corrected under Wikipedia’s Biographies of Living Persons policy.

1. 2019–2020 section

The article currently states:

“This matter caused a chain of events: Abrahall declared bankruptcy in order to forfend her debt to OSM; Abrahall commenced defamation proceedings against OSM; Abrahall's successor, Brian Mitchell, was dismissed.”

This is false. I did not declare bankruptcy, and there is no record of any bankruptcy filing. This claim should be removed.

Additionally, although I did commence defamation proceedings, this occurred in 2022, not during 2019–2020. Brian Mitchell was dismissed as President in May 2021, so this sentence is chronologically misplaced. It should be removed from the 2019–2020 section, and Brian Mitchell’s departure should instead be mentioned in the following section, where it belongs chronologically.

2. 2021–2025 section

The article states:

“In April 2022 Abrahall commenced defamation action against OSM; the case ended in March 2023 with the plaintiff voluntarily withdrawing her lawsuit.”

This is inaccurate. I commenced the defamation proceedings in May 2022, and the case was withdrawn by mutual agreement in March 2023, as confirmed by the court docket PACER Monitor, “Abrahall v. Open Source Matters, Inc.”, Case No. 1:22-cv-04086 (S.D.N.Y.). A neutral and accurate replacement for the disputed material would be:

“Abrahall commenced defamation proceedings against OSM in May 2022; the proceedings were withdrawn by mutual agreement in March 2023.”

The mutual withdrawal is confirmed by the PACER docket:

PACER Monitor, “Abrahall v. Open Source Matters, Inc.”, Case No. 1:22‑cv‑04086 (S.D.N.Y.), Stipulation of Voluntary Dismissal filed 31 March 2023.

Thank you. Datatonic (talk) 07:43, 8 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Partially done: I removed the uncited bankruptcy sentence. As for the defamation case, I simply trimmed the info down to what is indisputable. I am still mulling over the verifiability of the PACER source, as the filing itself is paywalled and the OCR summary provided garbles the lines and is thus inaccurate. Rotideypoc41352 (talk · contribs) 01:36, 26 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you would like a third opinion, please feel free to either ask for one at the biographies of living persons noticeboard or request another edit through the edit request wizard. Rotideypoc41352 (talk · contribs) 01:41, 26 October 2026 (UTC)Reply