Jump to content

Talk:Sub-Roman Britain

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 3 months ago by Andrew Lancaster in topic etymology: "Sub-Roman" ?

Map

[edit]

I've removed the map as the information it contains does not seem to be based on any reliable sources. Though there are occasional references to some of the kingdoms on the map in contemporary sources (such as those kingdoms mentioned in Gildas), there is little to locate them geographically, and certainly not to start drawing a complex network of borders on a map. Other kingdoms on the map seem to be inferred from later or earlier political entities, assuming that they existed in 500. As with many things on this period, great unknowns and grey areas are regularly glossed over in an attempt to give a coherent picture that can not be substantiated by the source material. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 62.253.219.157 (talk • contribs)

"St. Thaddaeus is described as visiting a Roman villa at Chepstow..."

[edit]

This is unsourced, and I think is based on a misunderstanding somewhere along the line. St Tathan, also known as Tatheus, is credited with founding a church at the former Roman town of Caerwent, about 5 miles from Chepstow - but was unconnected with St Thaddaeus. Can anyone clarify this statement (added by a long-departed editor back in 2007), or should it simply be deleted? Ghmyrtle (talk) 20:35, 5 December 2021 (UTC)Reply

Well, this Victorian Book of Saints references St “Tathai’s” (or “Tathaeus”) feast day “at Chepstow”. One of the name variants given for this saint is “Thaddaeus”. That seems to be St Tathan that’s being referenced - the name variant might be the basis of the confusion. It’s obviously not St. Thaddeus i.e. Jude the Apostle. It’s probably best to delete that sentence - not sure what it’s adding to a section that’s about sources anyway. DeCausa (talk) 22:21, 5 December 2021 (UTC)Reply
Stumbled across this more modern source that explicitly mentions “St Tatheus” visting the Chepstow villa. It also references Cuthbert’s visit to Carlisle. Could be used as a citation for examples of how saints lives texts provided insights on sub-Roman Britain - in afact I’ve gone ahead and added it and updated the text. DeCausa (talk) 09:11, 6 December 2021 (UTC)Reply
Thanks - though the modern source states "near" Chepstow, rather than "at" Chepstow. "Near" could refer to Venta Silurum at Caerwent. There is no firm archaeological evidence of a Roman villa "at" Chepstow - though of course it is possible that one or more existed. It would be good to find the origin of the "tale", apparently cited in Morris's Age of Arthur. Ghmyrtle (talk) 10:11, 6 December 2021 (UTC)Reply
The only primary source on Tatheus I’ve seen referenced is a 12th century Vita. But if the ‘tale’ came from that it’s a little dubious and late for modern scholars to use as a source for Sub-Roman Britain. Perhaps there’s something else. Maybe someone has access to Age of Arthur (it’s not on Google Books.) DeCausa (talk) 10:44, 6 December 2021 (UTC)Reply
I've ordered it - but I don't think it's now seen as a very reliable source, is it? Ghmyrtle (talk) 11:16, 6 December 2021 (UTC)Reply
It’s a bit out of date I think - but I would have thought a straightforward recounting of a story from a ms. would be ok though. In the Tathan article there’s a link to a 19th century translation of the Life of St Tathan but I couldn’t see anything about the visit in it. DeCausa (talk) 11:24, 6 December 2021 (UTC)Reply
Morris' The Age of Arthur refers to this place as "probably Portskewett" - which makes perfect sense, as Portskewett (4 miles from Chepstow, 2 miles from Caerwent) was a Roman and post-Roman settlement and port of some significance. Ghmyrtle (talk) 09:56, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Thanks, good find. Does Morris give a source for the story? The whole article needs quite a bit of improvement - little bit at a time I suppose… DeCausa (talk) 13:15, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Vita Tathei. That's the sum total of my knowledge on this! Ghmyrtle (talk) 15:00, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
I would only use Morris to find a source we can check. That book got torn apart. John Morris (historian). Doug Weller talk 15:57, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
It’s actually sourced to Nowell Myres who cites Morris. I actually had a look at a translation of the Vita previously and couldn’t find the story in it. I could well have missed it but maybe the whole thing is all a bit…weak. DeCausa (talk) 16:10, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
That's useless then. I don't trust Morris. Doug Weller talk 16:17, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Ok. I didn’t realise it was as bad as that. He wouldn’t even be trusted to accurately quote a story from a manuscript (Vita Tathei)? DeCausa (talk) 16:21, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
I can send you a Jstor review if you don't have access. Doug Weller talk 16:35, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
That’s ok. I’m sure you’re right. DeCausa (talk) 16:37, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
You can see this online.. Doug Weller talk 16:38, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
As an aside, might some of the criticisms of Morris book be mentioned in the article? Considering its cited multiple times without any disclaimer. For some reason only scholarship on migrations is really discussed as of yet. — jonas (talk) 07:32, 6 March 2026 (UTC)Reply
Here is the original story in translation, pp.17-18. "[They came] unto Britain, to wit to the Severn. At the last, being come through all the length of the strait they drew nigh unto Gwent and put in at a haven called after the name of the people ["i.e. some such name as portus Guentonie, the haven of Gwent"] ....Now a certain rich man who dwelt in that region, having a bath made ready for him (for such was his wont every Saturday), saw them drawing nigh, weary by reason of their journeying by land and sea.....". Ghmyrtle (talk) 16:43, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
We use the book at lot as a source. At least sometimes with criticism. Doug Weller talk 16:54, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Thanks, Ghmyrtle. But it does leave a question mark for this article. On what basis is this “a dilapidated Roman villa”? And on what basis is this evidence of continuation of a late Roman life-style into the sub-Roman period? All it says is there was a rich man who had a bath every Saturday. It doesn’t mention plumbing, a bath-house or a villa built in the Roman period whether dilapidated or not. (It could have been water warmed in a bucket over an open fire.) Is having a weekly bath a notable insight into sub-Roman Britain? Not sure. I don’t know, but it does look like Thomas over-reached wth this. Also, how does Thomas locate it to Portskewett? DeCausa (talk) 19:29, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Sub-Roman Britain includes the text we’ve been discussing here. The historical context section at History of Anglo-Saxon England looks problematic. Doug Weller talk 20:19, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Venta Silurum says he founded a monastery there. Doug Weller talk 20:24, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Most of the text in that sentence (including the "dilapidated Roman villa") is sourced to Myers here. He in turn cites Morris, who only refers (in the context of the 6th century) to "the owner of another estate, near Chepstow, [who] kept the baths of his villa in repair...". (Who is "Thomas" by the way?) There are other sources providing information (and speculation) about post-Roman settlement at Caerwent and nearby Portskewett - my initial interest was about what was meant by "near Chepstow", but I surmise that that was written by someone who does not live in the area ("near" is a very subjective term). Almost all of this article lacks reliable sources - at least that sentence now has citations. Ghmyrtle (talk) 21:41, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
Sorry, by Thomas I meant Morris! Not sure how i confused myself there. Yes, the citation is to Myers who in turn relies on Morris. Doug Weller points out that Morris (and any citation to Morris) is “useless” because his reputation has collapsed, unless one can check Morris’s source. Morris’s source is the Vita which you linked to. But that text doesn't reference any Roman villa at all. Morris appears to have misused his source, which seems consistent with his reputation. Based on that there’s a good case for taking it out of the article, even if much of the article is unsourced anyway. DeCausa (talk) 22:36, 30 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
This says Caradog gave Tathan Caerwent. I'm not convinced it's an rs. Tathan's article says he was an abbot of Caerwent based on a book by Fred Hando which seems a dubious source. As does the major source for the article, William Jenkins Rees about whom the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography says "y. The preparation of the society's edition of the ‘Liber Landavensis,’ at first entrusted to his nephew, Rice Rees [q. v.], was placed in his hands in 1839, and the book appeared in 1840. In 1853 Rees also edited for the society their collection of ‘Lives of the Cambro-British Saints’ (text and English translation). In neither case was the work, in the judgment of modern scholars, executed with due care and intelligence".. What a mess. Doug Weller talk 08:35, 31 January 2022 (UTC)Reply
I'm not an expert in any sense. But it occurs to me that a great deal of what sources - all sources - say about this period is based on interpretation of ancient writings that are capable of multiple explanations. Without completely rewriting articles like this one, or completely excluding all sources that some academics claim to be of dubious reliability, is anyone willing to highlight what is known to be true based on the most reliable modern analysis, and differentiate it by flagging up more contentious statements by contested writers? Ghmyrtle (talk) 09:02, 31 January 2022 (UTC)Reply

Should this article be merged away or reduced?

[edit]

It is very hard to maintain, build or improve such a forest of highly overlapping articles about Dark Ages Britain. In fact it is hard to even find all the articles. This one is not in good condition, and that makes sense. I see it has 2 sections with almost the same title. We also have articles with highly similar coverage: End of Roman rule in Britain and Anglo-Saxon settlement of Britain. The first overlaps especially with this one. The second overlaps with a section, and to work normally the sections here with main articles should be a summary of the main articles. Andrew Lancaster (talk) 15:17, 2 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

There is now discussion about this on one of the other articles here. I have written there as follows: The settlement period is more or less the same period as the Sub-Roman period. I can see an argument for saying that the focus upon the origins of the Anglo-Saxons can make the article different, but even if we don't merge we should make sure that the articles are "visible" to each other and clearly defined. Overlapping parts can sometimes be shortened, deferring to the other article. What I am seeing in practice is that the topics discussed overlap about 99% so something is wrong for now.--Andrew Lancaster (talk) 09:04, 3 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
This article overlaps more with End of Roman rule in Britain, which could probably be merged into this one. Anglo-Saxon settlement of Britain focuses on their settlement of (what is now) England, but this article should be about the whole island, focusing more on the Brittonic kingdoms and the Irish raids and settlement. I agree we should shorten the parts that overlap, and that could be done with Template:Excerpt. – Asarlaí (talk) 12:36, 3 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Of course we can re-name articles, and we don't necessarily need to base ourselves one what they are currently mainly about given that there seems to have been limited coordination. But in any case I think if we have an article with Anglo-Saxon settlement in the title then I think it should NOT be about Picts and Scoti? The "Brittonic" kingdoms are of course relevant and sometimes very intertwined with the Anglo-Saxons, but I think it would be odd to have a specific focussed discussion about them on such an article?--Andrew Lancaster (talk) 12:42, 3 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

etymology: "Sub-Roman" ?

[edit]

etymology: Sub-Roman Britain, also called post-Roman .... Xo4v (talk) 06:28, 12 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

If "post Roman" is a commonly used term for the same thing then it can be mentioned in the opening line, but is it?--Andrew Lancaster (talk) 06:44, 12 August 2026 (UTC)Reply