Jump to content

Wikipedia talk:Citing IMDb

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 1 month ago by Martin IIIa in topic "Newsgroup reviews"

WikiProject Film
General information ()
Main project page + talk
→ Discussion archives
Style guidelines talk
→ Multimedia talk
→ Naming conventions talk
→ Copy-editing essentials talk
Notability guidelines talk
Announcements and open tasks talk
→ Article alerts
→ Cleanup listing
→ New articles talk
→ Nominations for deletion talk
→ Popular pages
→ Requests talk
Spotlight talk
Film portal talk
Fiction noticeboard talk
Project organization
Participants talk
Project banner talk
Project category talk
Departments
Assessment talk
→ B-Class
→ Instructions
Categorization talk
Core talk
Outreach talk
Resources talk
Review talk
Spotlight talk
→ Spotlight cleanup listing
Topic workshop talk
Task forces
General topics
Film awards talk
Film festivals talk
Film finance talk
Filmmaking talk
Silent films talk
Genre
Animated films talk
Christian films talk
Comic book films talk
Documentary films talk
Marvel Cinematic Universe talk
Skydance Media talk
War films talk
Avant-garde and experimental films talk
National and regional
American cinema talk
Argentine cinema talk
Australian cinema talk
Baltic cinema talk
Belgian cinema talk
British cinema talk
Canadian cinema talk
Chinese cinema talk
French cinema talk
German cinema talk
Indian cinema
Kannada cinema
Malayalam cinema
Tamil cinema
talk
talk
talk
talk
Israeli cinema talk
Italian cinema talk
Japanese cinema talk
Korean cinema talk
Mexican cinema talk
New Zealand cinema talk
Nordic cinema talk
Pakistani cinema talk
Persian cinema talk
Southeast Asian cinema talk
Soviet and post-Soviet cinema talk
Spanish cinema talk
Uruguayan cinema talk
Venezuelan cinema talk
Templates
banner
DVD citation
DVD liner notes citation
infobox
invite
plot cleanup
stub
userbox

Clarification about WP:IMDB/BLP for date of birth

[edit]

The "Inappropriate uses" section reads: 1. Any potentially contentious material about living persons (BLPs). Could you please clarify whether using IMDb to support a BLP date of birth is okay or inappropriate? Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources#IMDb doesn't mention DOB, either. I've also read WP:BLPPRIMARY.

Context: I added a "citation needed" tag to a draft and the draft creator provided a link to IMDb and referred me to IMDb Biographical data guidelines which claims that some sort of proof (official document, social media link or LinkedIn link) is necessary.

Many thanks, Esowteric + Talk + Breadcrumbs 11:49, 30 June 2023 (UTC)Reply

IMDB is WP:SELFPUB. I find it good for looking up stats about an actor, such as what films they've been in and how many appearances in a TV show and if they had a named role. But information in articles shouldn't be cited directly to IMDB. It should be cited to other sources.
But anyway, to answer your question, no, I think using a self-published source such as IMDB to cite a birthdate is definitely against WP:BLPDOB. BLP tells us it is better to omit things like birthdates and middle names if they are not common knowledge, for privacy reasons. And the way to judge whether it's common knowledge is if it's been published in reliable sources. And IMDB is not reliable because it's self-published. Hope this helps. –Novem Linguae (talk) 22:54, 30 June 2023 (UTC)Reply
IMDb is 100% not acceptable for bio info (for WP:BLP) – that is long-standing policy. --IJBall (contribs • talk) 02:01, 1 July 2023 (UTC)Reply
Is there consensus on bio info for dead people? I'm asking because the inclusion of Patsy Doris Dittemore on the article Gosport, Indiana has IMDB as its only source. Rorb lalorb (talk) 23:09, 30 May 2025 (UTC)Reply
Thanks lot, guys. For additional context: I saw that this particular reality TV personality's date of birth is all over the place in Google searches, but not in reliable sources. Esowteric + Talk + Breadcrumbs 06:22, 1 July 2023 (UTC)Reply

Genre

[edit]

Is the media genre (drama, comedy, action, etc.) reasonable to reference directly from IMDB? Or perhaps only "objective" genres can be explicitly allowed per https://help.imdb.com/article/contribution/titles/genres/GZDRMS6R742JRGAG OceanLoop (talk) 22:50, 21 August 2025 (UTC)Reply

Again, please suggest alternatives

[edit]

Fine, IMDB is not a reliable source. So someone tell us what is! Without any guidance this negative guideline is not helpful. For an alleged cast member, should I find a movie review in a reputable publication, link to the movie studio's web site for the film (which tends to decay), find an article in an industry trade paper like Variety, or what?! This came up in Talk four years ago and there are some inconclusive suggestions there. I added Wikipedia:WikiProject Film/Resources to the project page's "See Also", but its resources don't include onefor the basic "Who's in the cast?"; the Academy Collection search is awful and the documents on DropBox seem to require signup. One recommendation is I should watch the movie and use {{Cite AV media}} to claim the information is in its closing credits, but be realistic, people are just going to go by what IMDB says and use that template to claim it's in the film. -- Skierpage (talk) 22:48, 17 December 2025 (UTC)Reply

== The Hypocrisy of Dismissing IMDb/TMDB: Industry Reality vs. Wiki Dogma ==
It is deeply ironic and hypocritical when Wikipedia or Fandom editors arbitrarily dismiss IMDb or TMDB profiles as "unreliable user-generated content" while operating on platforms where literally anyone—including minors with zero industry experience—can delete, alter, or sabotage verified articles based on personal whims.
The widespread "wiki narrative" that IMDb can be manipulated by anyone clicking a button is completely disconnected from how the global cinema industry actually functions. Editors throwing dirt on these databases need to understand that IMDb and TMDB are the master registries exclusively reserved for verified cinema professionals and multi-million-dollar official theatrical productions. These are tightly regulated industrial platforms, not social media forums.
1. The Paradox of Wikipedia's Vulnerability vs. IMDb's Security
Wikipedia criticizes database contributions, yet Wikipedia itself is notorious for allowing anonymous users to undo decades of meticulous archiving overnight. Conversely, IMDb is an industrial arm of Amazon, backed by a multi-billion-dollar corporate ecosystem. When an entertainment professional submits data, credits, or photographs to IMDb, it is never published instantly. It passes through an internal gauntlet of thousands of professional IMDb data editors who cross-verify submissions against official film contracts, credits billing blocks, and agency talent rosters. If the data is flagged, the system strictly demands verified documentation, such as official distribution contracts or studio call sheets, before approval.
2. Legal Custody and Industry Surveillance (The Role of Major Studios)
The cinema and documentary industry is built on strict union regulations (such as SAG-AFTRA, IATSE, and post-production guilds), multi-million-dollar copyright laws, and legal billing structures. Legal, PR, and distribution departments at major institutions like Warner Bros., Disney, National Geographic, or CERN vigilantly monitor the registries of their official releases.
·If anyone could casually inject their name, attach a fake photo, or insert unverified credits into these master registries alongside real industry titans, it would trigger instant legal and trademark infringement warnings from corporate lawyers, resulting in immediate removal and potential litigation.
·If these systems lacked oversight, the entire global history of cinema on IMDb/TMDB would be a chaotic wasteland of fake data. Instead, it serves as the official financial, legal, and historical backbone of the global entertainment business.
Conclusion
To claim that a verified, cross-checked profile on an industry-standard database—such as one maintaining a 100/100 Content Score evaluated by automated and human review—is "unreliable" while defending a system vulnerable to arbitrary deletion by non-professionals is pure institutional blindness. The industry stakeholders, producers, and official distributors have already vetted and mended these records. It is time for wiki moderation to look past rigid academic dogma and recognize verified cinematic registries for what they are: the official legal proof of a professional career. ~2026-41446-59 (talk) 05:38, 25 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
The entire premise of your argument - that Wikipedia itself is considered a reliable source on Wikipedia - is completely false. See WP:CIRCULAR. Martin IIIa (talk) 15:17, 5 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

"Newsgroup reviews"

[edit]

I deleted "#Newsgroup reviews, which are archived Usenet postings" from the list of "inappropriate uses", because IMDb no longer carries newsgroup reviews, and they haven't done so for a few years now. In fact, as far as I can tell, IMDb dropped newsgroup reviews sometime in 2013. -- Metropolitan90 (talk) 04:01, 10 January 2026 (UTC)Reply

Does the fact that IMDb no longer carries them matter? Web archiving services exist, and potentially so do existing citations of IMDb's newsgroup reviews. Martin IIIa (talk) 15:27, 5 October 2026 (UTC)Reply