Jump to content

Wikipedia talk:Neutral point of view

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 1 day ago by Katzrockso in topic Combining WP:PROPORTION and WP:DUE


Proposal: Restore the rationale for this policy

[edit]

I propose that the rationale for this policy be restored. This will allow editors and admins to make judgements concerning the policy. The rationale was formerly in the policy but was deleted:

Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, a compilation of human knowledge. But since Wikipedia is a community-built, international resource, we cannot expect collaborators to agree in all cases, or even in many cases, on what constitutes knowledge in a strict sense. We can, therefore, adopt the looser sense of "human knowledge" according to which a wide variety of conflicting theories constitute what we call "knowledge." We should, both individually and collectively, make an effort to present these conflicting views fairly, without advocating any one of them, with the qualification that views held only by a tiny minority of people should not be represented as though they are significant minority views, and perhaps should not be represented at all.

Hawkeye7 (discuss) 03:57, 21 July 2026 (UTC)Reply

  • Isn't the core of this just word salad? What does a wide variety of conflicting theories constitute what we call "knowledge." even mean? It doesn't correspond to what I understand as "knowledge", and it contradicts WP:NOT which states Wikipedia refects "accepted knowledge". What is the problem this text would solve? Bon courage (talk) 05:31, 21 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    WP:NPOV is one of the core content policies that is non-negotiable; WP:NOT is a policy, but it is not (not pun intended) a non-negotiable core content policy. So if something was introduced into WP:NOT that was in contradiction to something that was already in WP:NPOV, then the default would be for the latter to have priority.
    You have a POV. That's perfectly alright, we all do. I would argue that having "knowledge" about any subject on which disagreement exists requires hearing/reading what your ideological opponents say, and not exclusively what your ideological allies say about what they say. A knowledgeable atheist, for instance, will actually read the Bible himself (and there's plenty of fuel for atheist positions to be found in there); if he reads nothing but writings from other atheists then he won't be knowledgeable of either religion or atheism. Same applies the other way to a Christian arguing against atheism.
    This is because ALL POVs will misrepresent those they disagree with eventually, and not necessarily intentionally. It is unavoidable. If you only include one side, sooner or later there will be uncountered misinformation, and then everyone loses.
    Sorry for the essay... enjoy the rest of your day :). ~2026-40817-33 (talk) 19:05, 22 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    I wouldn't put too much stock in that "non-negotiable" language.
    First, it was added only because Jimmy Wales allegedly said that NPOV is "absolute and non-negotiable" in an e-mail thread, only the e-mail message that was cited isn't from him and doesn't contain those words (he is known to have said similar things in other discussions).
    Second, several of the policies have declared to be non-negotiable at various points, and eventually, people actually tried to sort out what that actually meant. Those discussions (example) resulted in several changes (example) that clarified that NPOV a fundamental principle that the community upholds, and not a rule saying (to give only one example of the ways it was misunderstood) that editors couldn't negotiate what the written policy should/shouldn't say. The result of the discussion was that editors discovered that NPOV isn't actually "absolute" (because it has to be interpreted with an eye on other policies) and that "non-negotiable" doesn't mean that Wikipedia:Negotiation is discouraged.
    Thirdly, all policies and guidelines are written and enforced by consensus, and that means, as a practical matter, that if the community ever stops supporting this policy, then it will stop being a policy in practice, and no amount of pounding on the table or wailing that the god-king of wikis said it will matter. We could (you know, if we were truly determined to damage Wikipedia) start a WP:PROPOSAL to gut this policy today. If the community suddenly, totally lost its mind, they might even go along with it. And if all of that happened, then it wouldn't matter one whit who said what 23 years ago, because in the end, the wiki way is that what the community supports is what sticks, and if they want to replace this policy with a feeble shadow of itself, there is no way to stop them from doing it.
    What we are actually (though badly) trying to communicate with this language is that the community currently objects to someone saying that NPOV can be outright ignored for this small group of articles (e.g., the 2026 Iran war because of soldiers' safety, Suicide because someone might die, Sexual practices between men because that's against some religions, or whatever). WhatamIdoing (talk) 20:49, 22 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    Yes! NPOV explicitly overrides WP:BLP. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 20:34, 23 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    @Hawkeye7, really? Explicitly? Explicit means that there's a sentence in this policy that says something like "This policy overrides BLP". However, I don't see any mention of the BLP policy in this policy at all. Could you quote for me the alleged "explicit" overriding statement? WhatamIdoing (talk) 17:33, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    This policy is non-negotiable, and the principles upon which it is based cannot be superseded by other policies or guidelines Hawkeye7 (discuss) 19:42, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    I was expecting something that explicitly mentioned the BLP policy. I wonder if there were any discussions when the BLP policy was adopted about whether NPOV should be considered to "override" it. I doubt that would have been acceptable. WhatamIdoing (talk) 02:42, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    There were concerns in the early days that some editors might favour BLP over NPOV (Wikipedia talk:Biographies of living persons/Archive 3#Concern over implications of this policy) Conflict between NPOV and BLP was noted, and inevitably NPOV won (Wikipedia talk:Biographies of living persons/Archive 3#Nutshell) "NPOV is uncompromisable". (Wikipedia talk:Biographies of living persons/Archive 4#Defamatory material in user namespace) "It would be harmful to the effective functioning of wikipedia as a NPOV encyclopedia to systematically limit discussion anywhere on wikipedia of negative unsourced material. NPOV trumps BLP." Hawkeye7 (discuss) 03:06, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    I'm not sure small discussion from 20 years ago dictate interpretation. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 10:31, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I would rather it mentioned that we should rely on sources for all of this, as it's something a lot of editors seem to struggle with. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 11:48, 21 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Any rationale must include reliable sourcing and some mention of fringe sources. Otherwise we open the door to woo, "scientific" racism, pseudoscience and conspiracy theories. Simonm223 (talk) 12:06, 21 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'd add a problem with this kind of broad abstract opening statement (MEDRS bears the scars of this), is that editors read it, stop there, and imagine they can extrapolate the whole policy from it in their head, and/or use that imagined extrapolation to override the specific wording that follows. So in general I think such statements are a bad idea. Is there any example anywhere on Wikipedia where the absence of this text has proved problematic, and where its addition would solve that problem? If so, examples please! Bon courage (talk) 13:42, 21 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
We could have a Wikipedia:Neutral point of view/Why page. WhatamIdoing (talk) 19:32, 21 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I like the idea of stating a rational at the start of policy pages… but… the specific language that was removed and is being proposed for restoration is, IMO, horrible - overly wordy and not at all clear. Needs workshopping. Blueboar (talk) 12:28, 22 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm less enthusiastic about providing a rationale. At some level, something is our policy/guideline/process because we choose to have it. For this particular page, I can imagine circumstances in which it'd be useful to have a "Dear friends in the media" explanation. WhatamIdoing (talk) 16:10, 22 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Well, as the man famously said: There are two things the public should never be told about, namely "how laws and sausages are made" . Now we can add policies to that as a third item, I think. Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 21:23, 22 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
NPOV differs from other policies because we didn't choose to have it; it was imposed from above and declared non-negotiable. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 20:32, 23 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
That's not factually true. First, Jimbo isn't "above"; second, he didn't create NPOV; third, the "non-negotiable" language just came from an ordinary discussion in a mailing list. The "non-negotiable" quotation used to be explicitly marked as just something he said once in this policy. Maybe we should go back to that. WhatamIdoing (talk) 17:36, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
We can go back to that as easily as we could unscramble a plate of scrambled eggs. Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 17:42, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think it'd take me about 10 seconds to change the sentence to its original form, which is According to Jimbo Wales, "NPOV is absolute and non-negotiable". That sounds much easier than trying to re-nature denatured proteins. WhatamIdoing (talk) 19:30, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Pronouncements by Jimbo have no place in current Wikipedia policy. —David Eppstein (talk) 19:41, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Once again, I would go further. Once upon a time, in a land called Northern California, there was a nice operating system called Berkeley Unix which gave a fortune cookie every time you logged in. One has stuck in my mind for decades: Whoever makes a significant contribution to any field of endeavor will in time become an obstacle to progress in that field. The size of the obstacle will be directly proportional to the size of the original contribution. Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 22:19, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you change that in 10 seconds without consensus, it will remain there for about 7 seconds. Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 21:58, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Jimbo didn't create NPOV; Larry Sanger did. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 19:42, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I believe the point is that the sentence comes from a quote by Wales. It's not present in Sangers original version. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 20:02, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
It does not matter who cooked the dish. What matters is: Is it good? Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 22:12, 27 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think there is a big difference between expressing something as an opinion of Jimbo Larry some Wikipedian and a categorical statement of immutable policy. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 03:24, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
This policy isn't immutable, it has changed over the years to reflect best practice. The outdated ideals of a quarter century ago have been refined and improved up on. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 10:33, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
My understanding is that all WP:5P are not subject to consensus (or, more specifically, they are core principles that consensus is used to implement, which carries the same implication; a consensus that unambiguously goes against the 5P is never valid, although of course one editor arguing that a consensus goes against the 5P isn't going to get them anywhere if people overall disagree with them.) I did notice someone in another discussion arguing that NPOV trumps OR because it has this explicit statement at the top (and I would assume they'd also argue it trumps WP:V); I don't think this is the case. All three are non-negotiable but all three are also of equal weight (in the sense that we cannot ignore any of them.) Also, of course, all three are derivable from each other; the requirement for verifiability and the prohibition against OR are natural consequences of NPOV, for instance. If people are using the statement on NPOV to argue that we can sometimes override the other two, I think we should consider a tweak to eliminate that interpretation (although I would lean more towards adding the same This policy is non-negotiable, and the principles upon which it is based cannot be superseded by other policies or guidelines, nor by editor consensus to OR and V to make it clear that the three are coequal; when they come into conflict, we have to find a solution that satisfies all of them, we can't just prioritize one and ignore the other. WP:CIVIL also falls under that category but it's not as important to clarify because it doesn't generally come into conflict with content policies. I do think that it's important as a principle because sometimes lesser (or just more specific) policies or guidelines can be overridden by core policy or the WP:5P, in situations where following an overly-specific lesser policy or guideline in a particular case would obviously contravene NPOV / OR / V. EDIT: That said, we might also tweak the wording down to just The principles this policy is based on cannot be superseded by other policies or guidelines, nor by editor consensus. The "non-negotiable" part is only half-true; editors cannot propose we ignore NPOV, OR, or V, but they can absolutely argue over interpretation and applicability in individual cases, and even tweak the wording as long as the core principle is maintained. It's the principle that is non-negotiable, not the specific text; the specific text is just an implementation. --Aquillion (talk) 03:37, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
See Wikipedia talk:Five pillars/FAQ. WhatamIdoing (talk) 03:57, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Editor consensus is based upon WP:CIVIL, so it does come into conflict with content policies on occasion. Since NPOV overrides consensus, it implicitly trumps CIVIL, and therefore the five pillars are not equal. Our three core content policies are NPOV, OR and V, all of which are derived from the NPOV pillar. BLP is not a core policy, although it is also derived from NPOV, so is an example of an " overly-specific lesser policy" that you were referring to. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 20:49, 29 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
NPOV doesn't override consensus. Consensus can, and has, changed the NPOV policy. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 14:33, 30 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Kind-of sort-of. I do agree with the interpretation that a consensus can't override the basic principle of NPOV. If we had a consensus somewhere that said "we should ignore the sources and just say Senator Smith is the best person ever, because it's really important that Senator Smith win this upcoming election", that would be illegitimate. That said, that isn't really unique to NPOV; consensus in general has to be based on policy, so any consensus that said "let's just ignore policy Y" without a competing policy reason (eg. "policy Z is controlling here and overrides it") or a really really strong IAR rationale is on shaky ground. But I do think there are policies that are stronger than others and which we have to prioritize when they come into direct conflict, and NPOV is one of the strongest (I would say that it is equal with WP:V and WP:OR.) This matters in particular because a lot of subject-specific or MOS stuff tells us to write specific things or in specific ways, and many of them were written under the unstated assumption of "the sources will always support this"; it's important that those don't override NPOV / V / OR for situations where that isn't true. It's important that "we should follow guideline X here" can be answered with "no, we can't do that here, it would contradict NPOV." (Caveat: of course people can disagree on whether that is true, so in practice, in most cases, what this means is that that "we should ignore guideline X here because it would contradict NPOV to follow it" is a valid argument, not that it actually lets you just walk around ignoring a consensus to the contrary.) Also, while we can tweak NPOV to better-reflect its spirit, and can argue about what its spirit means, I do think that we can't just go "NPOV no longer matters at all, let's delete this page"; arguments over NPOV have to be premised in some reasonable understanding of NPOV rather than just "let's just get rid of it, NPOV is for suckers" or the like. --Aquillion (talk) 15:46, 30 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
WP:CONSENSUS can't override the principle of any policy, as it states that it requires the following of Wikipedia's policies and guidelines. In the same way that NPOV requires that other policies be followed. They're interconnected, and you can't use part of one to say that another can be overridden or trumped. NPOV will be more important than MOS, but that's just a valid consensus argument rather than something special. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 16:04, 30 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree with you both, except that I want to be clear that we could actually have a consensus to delete NPOV ("policy", "page" and/or "principle"). IMO doing that would make Wikipedia stop being Wikipedia, and I doubt that the current community would stand for it, but it's possible. We can't get rid of NFCC or BLP because the WMF's board requires us to have those, but NPOV is currently optional, and even when it finally joins the list of mandatory policies, there is no requirement that it contain words like "non-negotiable".
We sometimes say that "consensus is king". It would probably be more accurate to say that consensus is gravity: It is an implacable and universal law that all voluntary associations abide by, and it is only through the expenditure of significant energy that you can temporarily overcome it. If "the community" wants something, a changeable page that is created and changed by that same community will not long stand in their way. We can show future generations that this is a good path, but we cannot force them to walk in it – not even by (mis?)quoting Jimmy Wales. WhatamIdoing (talk) 16:48, 30 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
I would agree with both points, that NPOV could be deleted as it's not a legal requirement, and that it would essentially mean that the project would no longer be Wikipedia. If anything BLP and NFCC should be the ones that state they're non-negotiable. We could turn the site into the POV pushing bogeyman that so many make money portraying us to be, but if we started adding endless libel and copyright infringing content then the WMF would likely take the servers offline until it was stopped. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 20:02, 30 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
BLP and NFCC are both negotiable. They should never be confused with libel and copyright infingement; they are quite distinct. FWIW, WMF only requires that we have a NFCC policy; there is some latitude in what it contains. There is no WMF requirement for BLP, which lacks a rationale, and derives its authority from Jimmy Wales. NPOV is not subject to consensus and cannot be deleted. This policy is non-negotiable, and the principles upon which it is based cannot be superseded by other policies or guidelines, nor by editor consensus. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 21:01, 30 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
WMF doesn't require projects to have project-specific BLP policies, but (unless I'm mistaken), the WMF has adopted their own, universal/global BLP policy (but their P stands for "people" instead of persons - I think "persons" is more correct), which enwiki would be bound by should it ever decide to abolish the enwiki BLP policy. So in that sense BLP is still "non-negotiable", even if our own BLP technically isn't. ~2026-40817-33 (talk) 22:32, 30 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
The WMF requires a BLP policy; see foundation:Resolution:Biographies of living people. Note the words at the top: It may not be circumvented, eroded, or ignored by Wikimedia Foundation officers or staff nor local policies of any Wikimedia project. According to that rule, "the global Wikimedia community to uphold and strengthen our commitment to high-quality, accurate information, by:
  1. Ensuring that projects in all languages that describe living people have policies in place calling for special attention to the principles of neutrality and verifiability in those articles;"
We therefore must have a BLP policy. WhatamIdoing (talk) 01:20, 31 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
You're quite right! I overlooked that. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 06:15, 31 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Hawkeye, I'm really not sure how you've gotten stuck in this hole, but let me take you through a series of steps, and maybe that will help you see this policy in a different light:
  1. This policy previously did not say anything about being non-negotiable. This was what the community chose to say on this page, at that time. The world did not end.
  2. This policy was changed to (allegedly) quote Jimbo saying that NPOV is "absolute and non-negotiable". This was what the community chose to say on this page, at that time. The world did not end.
  3. This policy was changed to remove the words "absolute and non-negotiable". This was what the community chose to say on this page, at that time. The world did not end.
  4. This policy was changed to add the words "fundamental principles". This was what the community chose to say on this page, at that time. The world did not end.
  5. This policy was changed to put back only the word "non-negotiable". This was what the community chose to say on this page at that time. The world still did not end.
The community has chosen several different things to say on this page, at different time. I suggest to you that:
  • This policy could, at any time the future, be changed again, to remove the word "non-negotiable" again. The community can choose not to have that word on this page, at any time, and the world would still not end.
Do you understand that the community is allowed to choose whether that particular word is on this page? WhatamIdoing (talk) 01:27, 31 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
We have some small leeway on BLP and NFCC, but their basic principles are non-negotiable as the WMF require Wikipedia to have them. The same is not true of NPOV, and it could be changed by consensus at anytime. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 13:54, 31 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
WMF was talking about requiring NPOV as well. (Proposed baseline NPOV standard) Note that it includes "This standard is not negotiable. Neither editor consensus nor other policies and guidelines can supersede the principle of neutral point of view." Hawkeye7 (discuss) 21:07, 31 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
So at the moment it isn't required. Even if that wording is included in the WMF version, that version is only suggested. No exact wording is required. So we could still remove the wording even if that is adopted, or add it to the V and OR. "The proposed baseline is meant for the Wikipedias which do not yet have an NPOV policy, for their communities to adopt, use, and build upon.", but we'll see what they say in mid-August. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 23:05, 31 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
Note, too, that I have strongly suggested that they change that wording. @Risker is involved in that work and might be interested in knowing that this discussion is happening here. WhatamIdoing (talk) 21:59, 1 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
The problem with the wording is that it encourages editors to get hung up on a single sentence, rather than taking all of policy and guidance into account. Single mindedly focusing on one sentence of a policy or guideline, to the exclusion of everything else doesn't usually end well. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 14:58, 2 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:23, 2 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • Please permit me to formally oppose the addition of the green text rationale at the top of the thread because it is reminiscent of a speech by some politician we have never heard of. It is pure rhetoric. I will make no further comments on this thread and predict that consensus will not be reached to implement the proposal. Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 04:06, 28 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    The reason I started this is that an editor told me that NPOV was for imposing American values on the project. I was hoping for a better rationale. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 20:52, 29 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    If the reliable sources for a given subject are all American (or nearly so), then NPOV means we'll have an article about the American view of that subject. That's likely to happen for some US subjects. For example, we have lots of articles about US highways, and I doubt that there is a non-US POV about most of them. However, the converse is also true: anything we write about most politicians in non-US countries will primarily be written from non-US sources, and therefore reflect sources with non-US values. WhatamIdoing (talk) 22:51, 29 July 2026 (UTC)Reply
    The converse is not true and is a common criticism of the English Wikipedia. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 19:45, 3 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
    The converse is not always true, but it is IMO often true, especially when editors use WP:NONENG sources. The main challenge is that we often just don't have the articles at all. For example, WP:NPOL says we probably should have an article on every member of every national legislature, and we probably don't. If we were to try to write those articles, we probably couldn't use primarily (or any) US sources for most of them, because US sources really don't spend much time writing about the individual elected legislators of most developing countries. List of legislatures by number of members says there are more than 47,000 legislators, and it doesn't include sub-national legislatures. We probably don't have articles on all of them, and even if we do, we'll have to use non-US sources, because my newspaper, at any rate, isn't running thousands of articles each year about non-US politicians. If we're to have sources, we will not be able to find US sources for these articles. WhatamIdoing (talk) 21:26, 3 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

The policy is about opinions, not bias

[edit]

I propose the following changes:

Attributing and specifying biased statements

Change to Attributing and specifying opinions

Biased statements of opinion.... change to "Statements of opinion..."

Avoid the temptation to rephrase biased or opinion statements... Take out "biased or"

The section equates, semi-randomly, having an opinion and being biased. They are not the same, and the need is clearly to specify policy on statements of opinion. Mevsherd (talk) 03:02, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

Saying "biased or opinion" does not conflate biased statements with opinion statements. Instead, it indicates that these are different, and that the rule applies to both. WhatamIdoing (talk) 03:37, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Even if that were true, it applies to one of the three proposed changes. In context here, I think it is not true. It also doesn’t make sense: sources are biased, and can make both statements of fact and opinion. I don’t know what “biased statement” could mean, other than shorthand for statement by a biased source. Mevsherd (talk) 14:35, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Yes, I think it means a statement from a biased source. For example, we should cite but not attribute statements about widely held opinions, e.g., that Elvis is considered one of the greatest rock stars of all time. Saying "Alice and Bob and Chris consider Elvis to be one of the greatest rock stars of all time" is not a neutral way to present a widely held opinion, because it implies that it's just their opinion, and that David and Eve and Frank (and everyone else) think something quite different. But we should attribute statements of opinion that come only from biased sources, e.g., that his own mother considered him to be one of the greatest rock stars of all time. "He's the greatest" without saying "according to his own mother" would not be a neutral way of presenting that opinion. WhatamIdoing (talk) 16:47, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm not sure if you're objecting to all my proposed changes, or none, or just the last one. A statement that an opinion is widely held would, presumably, be a factual statement, backed up by some survey or poll. So, it's not covered by the policy on opinions. If you're suggesting Wikipedia should state, as a fact, that Elvis is one of the greatest rock stars of all time, because many reliable sources say so, then I disagree. Mevsherd (talk) 19:54, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Biased without opinion happens all the time, by selectively emphasizing facts. Compare: "Candidate X voted against bill Y, which raised income taxes." to "Candidate X voted against bill Y, which funded local schools." Both factually true, but very different framings. The policy should maintain the distinction in all 3 places. MrOllie (talk) 20:05, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
All of that is strictly about facts though: Candidate X either did or didn't vote against the bill; the bill either would have raised taxes or it wouldn't have; it would have either funded schools or it wouldn't have. There are no opinions in there. WhatamIdoing (talk) 21:28, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
No, widely held opinions are not facts.
See the second sentence of Elvis Presley: "Often referred to as the "King of Rock and Roll or simply "The King"", he is widely regarded as one of the most culturally significant figures of the 20th century." This is (a) a fact about an opinion and (b) the correct thing to have in the lead of that Wikipedia article. WhatamIdoing (talk) 21:27, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
"one of the most" is a WP:WEASEL expression; any 20th century cultural figure notable enough to have a Wikipedia article would qualify. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 21:46, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
No, something is never WP:WEASEL if it reflects what the sources say directly (ie. if the sources say he's one of the most culturally significant, we should reflect that.) I don't agree that every cultural figure with a Wikipedia article would have significant sourcing saying the same thing. --Aquillion (talk) 21:52, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't think that even 50% of them could claim to be "one of the most". WhatamIdoing (talk) 03:36, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • It is also worth pointing out that people can sometimes disagree about what's an opinion and what's a fact. This is something that WP:NPOV touches on with its warning against phrasing widely-accepted facts as opinions. For example, there are people who would reject eg. the fact that Shakespeare wrote Hamlet, and therefore treat it as an opinion that we cannot state in the article voice; but the best available sources don't agree. Bias is important for evaluating this because biased sources may state their opinions as fact (but this leads to what I think is a subtle point that when Wikipedia policies say "bias", we almost always mean only biases that are outside the academic mainstream, or, at least, that biases matter more the further they are out of the mainstream; someone who feels strongly about the Shakespeare authorship question might attempt to frame every academic who disagrees with them as a Bardian and therefore biased towards concluding that Shakespeare wrote Hamlet, but that's not bias as we understand it.) --Aquillion (talk) 21:52, 20 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

In any case, I would appreciate discussion of the changes I proposed. The section in question is about statements. I think people have agreed that "biased statements" is (misleading) shorthand for statements by biased sources. But, the section in question is *not* about sourcing--there are other sections and whole pages and essays about that. There are also other sections, pages, etc about undue weight, article structure, and bias in general. This section is supposed to be about statements of opinion, except it confuses opinions and biased statements. For example, the second example I gave is: "Biased statements of opinion can be presented only with in-text attribution" That implies that unbiased statements of opinion need no attribution, which is wrong. And the meaning of "biased statements of opinion" is unclear anyway. Mevsherd (talk) 02:56, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

No, that implies, at the most, that unbiased statements of opinion sometimes need no in-text attribution, which is correct. WhatamIdoing (talk) 03:40, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
What are you talking about? Mevsherd (talk) 04:37, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I disagree with the claim you made: For example, the second example I gave is: "Biased statements of opinion can be presented only with in-text attribution" That implies that unbiased statements of opinion need no attribution, which is wrong.
Saying that "X need A" does not imply that "not-X do not need A". See List of fallacies#Propositional fallacies. WhatamIdoing (talk) 05:00, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Yeah no kidding, I didn’t mean implied like a syllogism. Meanwhile, note the policy I copied below which says opinions should be attributed in the text. Mevsherd (talk) 06:08, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Why don’t you read some basic policy. We could probably delete the section entirely.
Avoid stating opinions as facts. Usually, articles will contain information about the significant opinions that have been expressed in reliable sources about their subjects. However, these opinions should not be stated in Wikipedia's voice. Rather, they should be attributed in the text to particular sources, or where justified, described as widespread views, etc. For example, an article should not state that genocide is an evil action but may state that genocide has been described by John So-and-so as the epitome of human evil. Mevsherd (talk) 04:41, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Mevsherd, welcome to Wikipedia. I invite you to glance through User:WhatamIdoing#Policies and guidelines you can ask me about and then decide whether it's appropriate for you to be telling me to "read some basic policy". WhatamIdoing (talk) 05:06, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Yes, read some basic policy. You don’t know what you’re doing. Mevsherd (talk) 06:10, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
In my 20 years here, I've written more of Wikipedia's policies, including the policy on writing policies and guidelines, than you have made edits ever. If the two of us disagree about the intention of a policy, it is unlikely that I'm the one whose impression is wrong. WhatamIdoing (talk) 17:34, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Every statement of opinion (biased or not) needs in-text attribution to explain that it is an opinion and give context to why that opinion is held to make sure it is not said in Wikivoice. There are very limited exceptions such as a summaization of such opinions in the lede, or as like a leading transitional statement in prose (eg "Some experts believe X.(no source) Expert 1 says this (source). Expert 2 says that (source)..." etc. Masem (t) 10:53, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
This claim that every statement of opinion needs in-text attribution is not true. According to this policy, in-text attribution is not appropriate for opinions that are "described as widespread views, etc". WhatamIdoing (talk) 17:42, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
if something us a widespread view then you should be able to provide sources and context for why it is a wide spread view (most likely, secondary source or two far more recent than topic that itself incorporates other sources to provide that justification that has withstood the test of time and review), otherwise you are engaging in an original research conclusion from sources, and putting opinion in wikivoice. Masem (t) 13:56, 24 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
If the source states it directly it can't be original research. Sources are allowed to conduct original research to come to their conclusions, as OR applies to Wikipedia's content not it's sources. If reliable sources state something as fact then Wikipedia is required to do so as well, it's not upon editors to believes about the matter to determine if it is a fact. That would be introducing our own bias when that bias does not appear in the sources. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 14:16, 24 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
if an RS is stating a subjective statement as fact, we need to attribute it as a claim made by that RS. Eg if a single source says "Elvis was the greatest musician of the 20th", which is absolutely a subjective statement, it would have to be included in WP as "according to (source), Elvis was the greatest musician of the 20th century." There is zero bias or neutrality issue in adapting the "always attribute" approach for anything that could be subjective. Even if WEIGHT or FRINGE applies and there is only one stance that all sources that know a subjective matter, we still need to treat that as a subjective statement. We'd still write "Shakespeare is considered one of the world's greatest playrights" than "Shahespeare is one of the world's greatest playrights.", and would expand to explain why this subjective view is held, without need to address the opposite view if that is too undue. Masem (t) 14:41, 24 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
If a single source says that, sure. But what about when basically all the sources say that?
"Shakespeare is considered one of the world's greatest playwrights" does not contain in-text attribution. Remember: WP:INTEXT requires the name of the people/group who say that. In-text attribution looks like "Alice Expert says Shakespeare is one of the world's greatest playwrights" or "Bardian scholars say Shakespeare is one of the world's greatest playwrights". A mere assertion that unnamed persons or groups hold an opinion is not providing in-text attribution. WhatamIdoing (talk) 00:07, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
no, that phrase doesnt contain in text attribution but importantly, makes it clear it is still an opinion wisely held, so that phrase is NPOV compliant. And as long as we have quality sources that specifically make that broad assertion, describing the overall sentiment, those are good sources to include.
Contrast to "Shakespeare is one of the greatest playrights.", even if backed by the same high quality sources, is a problem as its presenting a subjective assessment as fact.
The other problem is that editors often want to use multiple sources to make claims about the whole which is the OR part. Say no sources directly discussed the broad stance of multiple commentators holding the opinion that Shakespeare being a great playwright, but instead we only had, say, 50 useable, high quality, non summary sources where the author claims he was a great playright, and further that there are no apparent sources that say differently. What is done too often and which is the NPOV/OR problem is saying that those 50 sources opining on this must make it a fact, particularly if there are no readily observed contested counterpoints. Nor can we use those soucves to conclude "Shakespeare is considered a great playright", because we cannot define to full picture from just 50 sources lest we engage in OR.
We can say "Many/some literary experts consider..." because we can back that up with the 50 sources and does not attempt yo define the full picture. (But we cant say "most" since that relates to the full picture that we cannot hope to assess). And per WEIGHT we are also not required to include any counterpoint statement if no reliable source can be found to make one. But the absence of any source that makes a counterpoint does not make the original opinion fact. We just habe to leave the fact that the broader picture is something we cant define any we can only capture the snapshot of sources we know we can find and use.
And with all of this, whenever we make such a broad claim of opinion, whether made directly or based on multiple sources saying the same thing, it should always have additional context to show how sources are basing that claim, which is where more durect in text attribution is expected. (Eg "Shakespeare is considered one of the worlds greatest playrights. Professor Jones of Oxford said that Shakespeare wrote eloquently...")
Maybe not in the lede, but definitely in the body. It helps both in our tone and for the reader to understand the basis for that opinion. Masem (t) 13:28, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree with you that in the case of subjective opinions, we have two policy-authorized options:
  1. In-text attribution to named people/groups, or
  2. Saying that the view is widely held/many experts believe/similar phrases.
The fact that there are two options means that your earlier, broad-brush sentence that "Every statement of opinion (biased or not) needs in-text attribution" is technically wrong. And I point this out not to "make you be wrong", but because the OP here seems to be struggling with the concept, which means we need to be more precise than usual. "Every statement" doesn't require in-text attribution; however, "Every statement" does need some indication that it's not just the opinion of whichever fan (or critic) wrote the Wikipedia article, and in-text attribution is one of the two listed ways to achieve that goal. WhatamIdoing (talk) 14:59, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
To step into the middle of a dispute that is focused on linguistic details, but would you be in agreement to say that every opinion statement needs some form of attribution. Either specific attribution in the form of in-text attribution, or general attribution in the form of saying it's a widely held belief. --Kyohyi (talk) 15:19, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
As long as people understand that not all statements are opinions, but actually statements of fact. Experts statements in the filed of their expertise are statements of fact. There seems to be a common misconception that anything outside of maths or hard sciences are just statements of opinion. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 15:37, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
to kyohyi, yes I generally on that, that in the case of a broad generalization given by hgigh quality tertiary or sevondary sources that describe broad summation, that direct in line attribition is not required. But I also add that when broad characterization statements are used like that, we should still be providing the additional context of in line attribution as to why the generalization is held, instead of just throwing the broad claim out there without context.
But to this point above Experts statements in the filed of their expertise are statements of fact needs cavaets. If an expert makes a statement that is novel, not supported (yet) by any other sources, and not yet subject to any type of peer review, we should still be treating that as a claim requiring attribution. (Like "According to the New York Department of Labor, job growth in the state was 3% in July 2026"). And no matter how much one is an expert, making a statement that involves something that cannot be objectively proven ever should never be presented as fact. Eg, when someone dies by suicide, many experts in psychology will present likely reasons that the person took their life but we can never know for sure, so even if they all agree on the reasons, these still should always be presented as statements of opinion (either in line attribution or broad summary with appropriate sourcing and added context). Masem (t) 16:04, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
In re "we should still be providing the additional context of in line attribution as to why the generalization is held, instead of just throwing the broad claim out there without context":
What kind of "additional context" is needed for a statement such as "Shakespeare is widely considered one of the best playwrights"? I don't think that further elaboration is necessary.
(MOS:SUICIDE, as well as all of those experts, discourages public speculation on why someone killed themselves.) WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:37, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
because at least to me as a reader if you are just providing that without in text attribution and just relying on the citations, that doesnt help me put that statement in context. Even with the citations there, it reads as a "trust me bro" statement if left like that in the body. Having additional statements helps to bolster to support for that broad opinion and gives the reader more context at the reference work level. Masem (t) 18:58, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Again: What actual context is needed for that statement? To illustrate what you mean by "context", can you re-write the sentence ("Shakespeare is widely considered one of the best playwrights") so that it contains the "additional context" that you want to see? WhatamIdoing (talk) 04:55, 26 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't think that defining all expert opinion as "fact" is ultimately going to help editors. Editors have to use good Wikipedia:Editorial judgment to determine when in-text attribution is needed, when an inline citation is enough, or even when nothing is needed (e.g., summarizing the rest of the article). (And one of these days, I need to write that essay.) WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:20, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
“Shakespeare is considered…” is also passive voice, which I think Wikipedia calls “weasel words.”
Saying an opinion is “widespread” can be a factual claim. That’s most obvious when it is backed by a survey, but also true when there’s some expertise, e.g. the head of a climatology organization describing the views of climatologists. But, experts often disagree, so that kind of source is risky. When deemed factual by “consensus” it doesn’t need in-text attribution, just sourcing.
It can also be an opinion, an impression, basically the second case I mentioned above but without expertise, but that wouldn’t usually belong in an article.
The opinion itself, e.g. “Shakespeare is the greatest” is just an opinion, and needs to be attributed regardless of its popularity. Mevsherd (talk) 16:17, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
as WP:WEASEL points out "is considered" can be but is not always a weasel wording. Hence the need to back it with sourcing explicitly that talks about thr broad summary view and context explanation to justify its use. Masem (t) 16:52, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Also MOS:PASSIVE officially encourages appropriate use of the passive voice in Wikipedia article. Miss Snodgrass would doubtless be horrified. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:17, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I wonder if the difference between Wikipedia:Attribution to a reliable source and mentioning the source's name WP:INTEXT is insufficiently clear. AD is correct: If the source states "Shakespeare is widely considered to be one of the world's greatest playwrights", then it cannot be a violation of Wikipedia:No original research. "On Wikipedia, original research means material—such as facts, allegations, and ideas—for which no reliable source has ever been published". As soon as an editor says "Here's a Wikipedia:Published source that says exactly that", it cannot be OR to put that claim into a Wikipedia article.
The bits that seem to be confused look like this:
  • "Shakespeare is widely considered to be one of the world's greatest playwrights.[encyclopedia][book][scholar]"
    • This sentence is attributed to three reliable sources via inline citations. (Assume for the purpose of this exercise that the three cited sources say something that is close enough to the sentence that the sentence can be verified in each of them, but not quite so close that it'll get removed as a violation of WP:Close paraphrasing.)
    • There is no in-text attribution. If the view expressed in this sentence is widespread, then the absence of in-text attribution to one or more individuals is correct.
  • "Alice Expert says that Shakespeare is one of the world's greatest playwrights.[Alice's book]"
    • This text has in-text attribution to Alice. However, it only has one inline citation..
    • If the view attributed to Alice is widespread, then it is a violation of WP:NPOV to use in-text attribution to imply that only Alice holds this view.
WhatamIdoing (talk) 00:17, 25 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Given that the policy that I quoted above says "an article should not state that genocide is an evil action," and it is obviously a widespread view that genocide is evil, you appear to not know policy. Mevsherd (talk) 17:48, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
If you mean, sometimes we can say "Elvis is widely regarded as...." that is fact-based, i.e. has to be sourced to some survey or poll of how people regard Elvis. It's true, there's some subjectivity in what to call "widespread," but there is a factual basis (e.g. 51% or 67% of some relevant group). We are not stating, unattributed, the opinion that Elvis is great, merely summarizing the fact of some survey result. Mevsherd (talk) 17:56, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
We can say "Elvis is widely regarded as...." whenever we have a reliable source that directly supports this statement. The reliable source does not have to be relying on "some survey or poll of how people regard Elvis". Reliable sources are not required to name their sources, be based on surveys, or anything else.
Given sources like these:
  • Expert, Alice (2001) "Elvis: The Most Superlative." J. Culture and Entertainment p. 134–145.
  • Reporter, Rae (2014) "Chapter 2: Elvis". Cultural Icons of the 20th Century. Random Harper. ISBN 978-1234567897.
that say things like "is unquestionably the most important cultural icon from the mid-20th century" or "Of course everyone knows that Elvis is the best, the greatest, the most important, the most widely recognized American cultural figure of the last hundred years", then we can write that Elvis is "widely regarded as one of the most culturally significant figures of the 20th century" in the Wikipedia article. There does not have to be any poll, survey, or anything else behind the reliable sources' assertions. If these are reliable sources, then we can rely on them even if we do not know how the source came to that conclusion, and even if we would personally name some other cultural figure. WhatamIdoing (talk) 19:52, 21 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
There are two topics here. The main one is whether widespread opinions need in-text attribution, or can be stated as fact. They need attribution. This isn't right: This claim that every statement of opinion needs in-text attribution is not true. According to this policy, in-text attribution is not appropriate for opinions that are "described as widespread views, etc". No policy says "Taylor Swift is cuter than Kierkegaarde" can be stated as fact, even if a reliable source says it is a widespread opinion.
Please explain the difference, relative to the policy on attributing opinions, between "genocide is an evil action" and "The cultural impact of Elvis Presley was seismic" Both are widespread views.
The other topic is what constitutes a reliable source for a factual claim that a view is "widespread," e.g. "Taylor Swift is widely regarded as cuter than Kierkegaarde." Again, this example using Elvis Presley is incorrect:
[reliable sources say] "is unquestionably the most important cultural icon from the mid-20th century" or "Of course everyone knows that Elvis is the best, the greatest, the most important, the most widely recognized American cultural figure of the last hundred years", then we can write that Elvis is "widely regarded as one of the most culturally significant figures of the 20th century" in the Wikipedia article
First of all, the sources don't say what your summary of them says. But, even if they did, they are merely expressing their opinions: an opinion does not become a factual statement merely by existing in a reliable source.
A factual statement that a view is held by most people is a statistical claim, so the only reliable source in the context of a factual claim like “X is widely believed…” would be a survey (I’m not saying we have to cite the primary source itself). Presumably, in order to fairly summarize the survey results as “widespread”, the survey would have to find 51% or 67% of people hold the view (there's aways discretion in how to summarize facts). Without a poll as a source, a statistical claim like "the view is widespread" is just an impression or opinion, and must be attributed. This discussion does highlight how the same language can be either a factual claim or an opinion, and the sourcing tells the difference. Mevsherd (talk) 15:39, 22 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • You appear to disagree with what the policy says about whether widespread opinions need in-text attribution. That's okay: you are entitled to your opinion. Your disagreement doesn't make the policy stop saying what it says, and it doesn't stop the community agreeing on what the meaning is.
  • I wonder how you can conclude that the sources don't say what your summary of them says when I have given you hypothetical sources for the purpose of illustrating the type of source we would expect such a claim to be cited to. Perhaps you didn't understand that there are no authors named "Alice Expert" or "Rae Reporter"?
  • I recognize your belief that the only reliable source in the context of a factual claim like “X is widely believed…” would be a survey. However, the consensus in the community is that sources can be reliable for this particular type of comment even if there are no surveys or other primary sources behind them. "Just an impression", by a source who is reliable for that kind of impression, is sufficient. Again, you don't have to like it. You don't have to agree with it. You do have to accept that the community has chosen this approach. (Acceptance does not imply agreement; you may accept that the community has chosen this approach, and add in the same breath that in your opinion, the community is completely wrong to do so.)
WhatamIdoing (talk) 00:53, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
When it comes determining whether to attribute or not, my rule of thumb is: if there is any question, attribute. It may not be necessary to attribute, but it is never “wrong” to do so. Blueboar (talk) 01:07, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
It is sometimes wrong to provide in-text attribution, according to WP:INTEXT:
---
"When using in-text attribution, make sure it doesn't lead to an inadvertent neutrality violation. For example, the following implies parity between the sources, without making clear that the position of Darwin is the majority view:

X markN Charles Darwin says that human beings evolved through natural selection, but John Smith writes that we arrived here in pods from Mars.

checkY Humans evolved through natural selection, as first explained in Charles Darwin's The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex.

Neutrality issues apart, there are other ways in-text attribution can mislead. The sentence below suggests The New York Times has alone made this important discovery:

X markN According to The New York Times, the Sun will set in the west this evening.

checkY The Sun sets in the west each evening.

---
I'm sure that you would have no difficulty deciding whether these statements would benefit from in-text attribution, but many editors have neither your intuitive grasp of Wikipedia's approach nor your experience. WhatamIdoing (talk) 02:04, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
That doesn’t mean the attribution itself is “wrong”, it means we need to be careful not to present attributed statements as if they had equal weight. Blueboar (talk) 13:50, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
The above is copied from WP:INTEXT, which clearly indicates that this is wrong. "According to The New York Times, the Sun will set in the west this evening" is wrong. That is why there is a big red [mark|23x23px] next to it. This may be their prediction (and all predictions can be fairly considered to be "opinions" rather than "facts"), but it is wrong to use in-text attribution for that kind of claim. WhatamIdoing (talk) 16:32, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Your denial of reality would be interesting, if it weren't so destructive to the project.
Policy, quoted to you the 1st time: "...an article should not state that genocide is an evil action but may state that genocide has been described by John So-and-so as the epitome of human evil."
The 2nd time: "...the policy that I quoted above says 'an article should not state that genocide is an evil action,' and it is obviously a widespread view that genocide is evil..."
Referenced a 3rd time: "Please explain the difference, relative to the policy on attributing opinions, between 'genocide is an evil action' and 'The cultural impact of Elvis Presley was seismic' Both are widespread views."
Another official statement of the policy:
"For instance, the article on Shakespeare should note that he is widely considered one of the greatest authors in the English language by both scholars and the general public. It should not, however, state that Shakespeare is the greatest author in the English language."
The policy makes it very clear that widespread opinions should not be stated like facts.
I don't think you've quoted any policy in this discussion, have you? Mevsherd (talk) 03:52, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • This policy, as quoted by me above, says that it is acceptable when justified for opinions to be "described as widespread views". You even quoted this line of the policy back and asserted incorrectly that "No policy says" that. See also the line you quoted about Shakespeare, in which this policy recommends including the opinion that Shakespeare is widely considered one of the greatest authors and does not recommend including in-text attribution ("by both scholars and the general public" is not specific enough to attribute the opinion "to its source").
  • Nobody is required to WP:SATISFY you with explanations about the nuances of this policy. This is the policy because this is what the community chose for its policy. If you don't understand it, then that happens, but it does not impose an obligation on anybody else to remedy your lack of understanding.
WhatamIdoing (talk) 04:11, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Yes, the fact that an opinion is widespread is to be treated like any other statement of fact. And, a widespread opinion is to be treated like any other opinion: attributed in-text. Mevsherd (talk) 04:34, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Based on your complaints at Wikipedia:Village pump (idea lab)#Wikipedia's Standards Are Pathetic, and the responses to them, and after glancing through some of your contributions, I am not convinced that Wikipedia is an appropriate hobby for you. WhatamIdoing (talk) 04:47, 23 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
They're either incredibly dense or a very skilled troll. In either case we seem to be wandering close to NOTHERE. Intothatdarkness 16:33, 26 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • Belatedly, thinking about this discussion, one thing that occurs to me is that it might be worth considering if WP:BIASED is ultimately about due weight. The real reason biases require attribution is because without those we might be giving that perspective undue weight; this is why, for example, we don't need to attribute or qualify a statement that Shakespeare wrote Hamlet, because it is so broadly-held among high-quality sources that it would be undue to qualify it. Conversely an argument that eg. Francis Bacon wrote Hamlet is WP:FRINGE to the point where it would only really be mentioned on a few specific articles directly touching on it (per WP:ONEWAY), and, when it is mentioned, would be treated as an opinion with careful attribution. Anyway, the idea that it is ultimately about how much weight a perspective should be given might be useful when there is disagreement over whether something is a contested opinion or well-accepted fact - eg. "are the people who contest this so marginal that we can (and, sometimes, must) omit them completely". --Aquillion (talk) 05:32, 26 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
    Who wrote Hamlet is a factual question. Whether Taylor Swift is cuter than Kierkegaarde is an opinion. For our purposes, it doesn't matter that the world's answers are equally one-sided--that 95% of almost everyone thinks Shakespeare is the author and Swift is the cutie. We don't need in-text attribution of "Shakespeare wrote Hamlet" and we do need it for "Taylor Swift is cuter." Mevsherd (talk) 16:12, 26 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • Who wrote Hamlet is a factual question - there are people who would disagree with that statement. In fact, it was at one point such a controversial statement that we had an entire ArbCom case because prior efforts failed to resolve it. Therefore, we need policies that can help us resolve such disputes. Treating it as always being transparently obvious what is opinion and what is fact is unhelpful because it provides us with no guidance whatsoever for situations where it is less obvious. For another example that came up elsewhere, consider the question of whether Al Qaeda is a terrorist organization. Some people consider the term "terrorist" to always be an emotive statement of opinion; others consider it to be, that particular case, a dispassionate statement of objective fact. How do we resolve this? Or consider the statement that Taylor Swift is more impactful - fact or opinion? Questions like these make me extremely skeptical of any argument that resembles "well my gut says this is an opinion" or "well it's just obviously an opinion". In the more unclear cases it amounts to an editor asserting that we should substitute their own perspective for what the sources say, and in cases that you'd expect to be clear-cut (eg. who the fairest in the land is) the best sources ought to treat it as an opinion themselves, which makes me cautious when editors start asserting that we don't even need to look at them. If it's so obvious then there's no harm in relying on the sources to settle it in that case, too, if it ever actually reaches the point of being a serious conflict between editors. --Aquillion (talk) 16:28, 26 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
    There is no disputing that who wrote Hamlet is a factual question. There may be some dispute about the answer, but that just proves that people don't always agree on the answers to factual questions. One cannot begin to understand NPOV without understanding the difference between fact and opinion, and an great meany editors with 10+ years here and admins don't seem to understand the difference. People keep insisting that a widely-held opinion is a fact, and a disputable factual claim is an opinion. Wikipedia needs to improve its education around its NPOV policies. Mevsherd (talk) 05:10, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
The main motivation for creating WP:BIASED was the number of editors claiming that a source couldn't be used (at all) because it was "biased". This was mainly a problem in political content ("You can't cite that; the author's a known Demican/Republocrat/Greebertarian/etc"). WhatamIdoing (talk) 05:56, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
This still happens, but it now happens at RSN where people vet sources based off of ideological bent. --Kyohyi (talk) 12:37, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Then they are not following policy, they are doing whatever they want. The task remains, we need the "reliable source", so we have to agree on it. Unless the argument is there is no such thing as a reliable source, it has to be identified. -- Alanscottwalker (talk) 12:58, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
thats a problem. Bias alone cannot make a source unreliable, though a source so biased as to cause the source to publish falsehoods w/o corrections, or drop normal editorial practices to push their bias, obviously should be treated as unreliable (breitbart is a good example if bias overtaking editorial practice). But just because a source strongly leans left or right doesnt immediate make ot unreliable. Masem (t) 13:39, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
At this point I must have commented "Bias doesn't make a source unreliable, per WP:RSBIAS" about a thousand times at RSN, if not more. Editors still makes comments complaining about a sources bias, whether in discussions about the Washington Free Beacon or Democracy Now! For formal discussion it's up to the closer to give those comments less weight, if they don't the close should be challenged. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 15:15, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
It usually isn't so obvious a statement of this source is biased. The presentation is more this source engages in bad-think therefore unreliable. Or this source engages in good-think, therefore, reliable. Where they should more be based on, "this source engages in promoting specific advocacy, therefore should be treated as attributable opinion." --Kyohyi (talk) 15:25, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
People regularly raise for discussion the most mystifying sources at RSN, but that's rather the bound to happen. Partly it is on account of the universal scope of our articles, and partly on the need to work through the issues given the universal scope of the editorship. The need for discussion is rather a symptom of the open editorship than any closed system. Alanscottwalker (talk) 16:10, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Good think, bad think is just bias with different wording. Most source bias is less advocacy and more that everything has a constant slant to it. Something that advocates for or against LGBT rights is easily dealt with, usually without having to have discussion at RSN. As editors own good judgement should be able to see and balance those opinions. Sources that aren't so obvious are far more problematic, as they push a POV while claiming to be neutral. It usually those sources that end up being unreliable, as they ultimately allow that bias to slant reports at the expense of it's integrity. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 17:33, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
The issue at WP:RSN is that there are sources whose biases interfere with their accuracy to the point where they no longer have a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy. My experience is that in cases like that, people will try to defend them by effectively saying "you can't declare them unreliable, they're WP:BIASED!" as though BIASED is an affirmative defense for actual inaccuracy. And the fact-vs-opinion divide plays into this because sources are often found to be unreliable because high-quality coverage constantly faults their positions across a range of topics (vaccines, COVID, global warming, the 2020 election, etc) where particular sorts of bias have historically led sources to publish actual misinformation. Editors' preconceptions and our own biases can seep into this because, depending on our actual views on those topics, we might weigh high-quality coverage describing misinformation related to them differently (ie. there are absolutely editors who would describe some of those things as debatable differences of opinion and who would dismiss sources describing coverage as misinformation as themselves being biased / opinion / etc.) The only way out of that morass is to weigh coverage of a source itself according to source quality, WP:DUE, etc., which requires guidelines somewhere that help us resolve debates over what's a fact and what's a contested opinion. --Aquillion (talk) 17:52, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Years ago, I asked the question reputation among whom, and I don't believe I have ever received an answer. Functionally it seems to be reputation amongst Wikipedia editors, so we go back to the bad-think therefore unreliable and good-think therefore reliable which I brought up before. --Kyohyi (talk) 18:01, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
hence why the basis for relianle/unreliable should solely be based on demonstration of editorial control (fact checking, redaction or noted corrections when wrong). Overly biased sources will forgo editorial oversight making those easily unreliable. No judgements of bias shpuld enter that, only what happens as the result of extreme bias. Masem (t) 18:24, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Either directly by showing that the reporting isn't accurate, or better by secondary sources calling into question the reliability now the source. That's not a difficult question to answer. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 18:31, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Not difficult, but the answer is also circular. Source A says thing, Source B criticizes A, Source C criticizes B, source A Criticizes C. Which source is reliable? --Kyohyi (talk) 18:34, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Do you have any instances of what seems an unlikely situation? Usually when a source has issue with it factual reliability that situation doesn't occur. Sources may differ in opinion, but sources are usually able to agree on facts. If an event happened, sources may differ on it's causes, but any source denying that it happened has a problem. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 18:40, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think sources regularly differ on which facts are salient, and it used to be in vogue to call sources not presenting the facts you think are salient front and center as misinformation. I can also think of instances where a source presents a fact, other sources say its presentation is a half-truth, and editors taking that original fact as false. --Kyohyi (talk) 18:59, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
If sources differ on salient facts, you can do a number of different things, compare and contextualize them with more sources, decide its best to use both, and examine one and the other's track record, expertise, means, and method and discard, etc. -- Alanscottwalker (talk) 19:22, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
What facts are salient isn't a reliability issues, a source can't be unreliable about something it doesn't report. That's a issue with making sure to find reliable sources to cover all points of view. If a source doesn't cover something due to bias then find a source that does, and weigh sources to see what to include or not. Unless it's a fringe view, or one so minor it shouldn't be included, then there should be reliable sources somewhere that cover it. As an example in the article about the world being round it would be easy to find sources saying it was round, and others pointing out that technically it's a spheroid, as well as sources saying that some people incorrectly believe it to be flat. But if you can't find a reliable source for the world being a cube, that's not an issue with source reliability. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 20:12, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
The key point you're missing is that we only use the detailed rules of WP:RS to evaluate sources that are in dispute. With that in mind, the answer to where that reputation for fact-checking and accuracy exists is that it is among reliable sources, yes; and yes, this does mean that our existing list of reliable sources functionally polices itself and is self-reinforcing. How could it work any other way? We are neither researchers nor oracles, capable of divining the truth ourselves; we maintain a list of reliable sources, reflecting a particular self-reinforcing and consistent definition of reliability, which some people might reasonably disagree with. Fortunately, there are enough sources out there that are unquestionably reliable that, when there is a split between two quarreling sources accusing each other of publishing misinformation, we can look at the highest-quality sources, which we know to be reliable, to settle the issue. This is why we say that Wikipedia has an WP:ACADEMICBIAS. There are certainly, for instance, some outlets that spew misinformation about climate change or vaccines, which attempt to call essentially the entire academic establishment misinformation; but our detailed rules for reliable sources are only necessary for sources that are in serious dispute, and their arms, so to speak, are not long enough to box with all of academia. When the New York Times and Newsmax call each other biased, if those were the only sources in the universe and existed entirely in a vacuum, you might be able to try and convince editors that it's just a quarrel between opinions and that we have no way to determine the answer; but that's not the case, both sources (and the underlying conflict between them over eg. climate change) have substantial high-quality academic coverage. And when we look at that it immediately becomes obvious that Newsmax is the one publishing misinformation, with no serious efforts at fact-checking and no serious attempt to be accurate; the way we would have to cut the landscape of conflicting claims that would allow it to avoid that conclusion would require that we disregard basically every source we know to be reliable and end up with a tiny bubble of self-reinforcing sources that have no credibility anywhere else. This is also why, in RSN discussions, I try to cite peer-reviewed academic coverage whenever possible. There are certainly some people out there who believe that Newsmax is reliable and that all of academia is misinformation, but that's not really a way to write an encyclopedia. --Aquillion (talk) 22:57, 27 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
The problem with an academic bias is that people only actually see academia as an authority within the hard sciences. When you get into politics, morality, or social theory, or largely any field that isn't a hard science academia isn't authoritative on the "correct" answer. So when wikipedians come in and say well Academia says this is the right way we aren't genuinely reflecting human knowledge. --Kyohyi (talk) 12:25, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
The idea that outside hard sciences and maths everything is opinion just isn't true, it's a very narrow perspective of a minority. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 13:29, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Most stuff outside of sciences and math are unprovable assertions. (Even within sciences we have multiple theories because it is either beyond our current abilities to prove, or requires proving a negative which is impossible). We get sources making their best guesses based on observation and study (baised or not), and more academic/summary ones that talk to prevailing theories, but much of that should not be presented as readily demonstratable objective fact, instead be treated as subjective statements. Ideally, we have expert sources with minimal bias that we can attribute those to the weight and authority of the experts, but we should still be describing the base statement outside of wikivoice to avoid claiming it as an objective fact. Masem (t) 13:44, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Ahh, the strawman. It isn't everything is opinion, it is that the further you deviate from maths and hard sciences, the more normative and opinionated the subject becomes. Further, people treat (especially wikipedians) the criticism of the normative factors as if they are criticizing the factual statements. Sure we might be able to break out the facts from the opinions in fields outside of maths and hard sciences, and honestly we should, but we don't. So let's not pretend that they don't exist, people legitimately criticize them, and academia's opinions are still opinions. --Kyohyi (talk) 14:08, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
"the further you deviate from maths and hard sciences, the more normative and opinionated the subject becomes" - academic disciplines have no physical location; it is not possible to measure the distance between ideas; you're arguing metaphors. History is no less true than quantum physics. Poetry is not more subjective than geometry. Levivich (talk) 14:27, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't agree. WhatamIdoing (talk) 19:57, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
That's an opinion, and not one that's universally held. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 22:43, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
No, but it's fair to say that it is generally more subjective. Mevsherd (talk) 14:32, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Generally doesn't mean always. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 22:42, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
that's not really a way to write an encyclopedia—except Conservapedia. And https://www.freewiki.eu/en/index.php?title=Welcome_to_FreeWiki . And https://en.anthro.wiki/Main_Page .
I mean that the fact that Wikipedia is heavily based upon mainstream science is a wilful choice. I approve of this choice, but it remains a choice that has been made by the Wikipedia Community. If it were up to Larry Sanger, that would not have happened. tgeorgescu (talk) 03:50, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
About "you can't declare them unreliable, they're WP:BIASED!": I think that this often means "you can't declare them unreliable, solely because they're WP:BIASED!"
Think back to Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 444#RFC: The Telegraph on trans issues. The word bias appears 339 times(!) in the discussion. Editors ultimately concluded that bias alone doesn't prevent even a conservative newspaper from getting their facts straight. WhatamIdoing (talk) 19:52, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
About the overall problem, namely that AD keeps needing to repeat the basic fact that WP:RSBIAS is one of our rules, I have a couple of ideas (numbered for your convenience):
  1. We could add a message to the top of RSN that says that if you post at RSN asking whether a source is 'reliable' because you think it's biased, we're going to forcibly move your discussion to NPOVN.
  2. We could create a boilerplate message template to post at RSN and similar discussions that says something like "Bias doesn't make a source unreliable, per WP:RSBIAS", and encourage editors to use it. A cheatsheet for RSN regulars, with a handful of messages, could make responses much faster there. (I'd suggest that the first one in such a list be "Because RSCONTEXT, the reliability of the source cannot be judged separately from the claim you want to support. Please follow the directions above about naming the specific article and the exact sentence you have in mind".)
  3. We could undertake a general education campaign that includes this information. For example, the Echo/Notifications system allows local communities to send their own messages, so we could decide, e.g., that when you make your 20th edit, you should get a message that says "Please don't use an LLM", and at the 55th edit, you get one that says "ICYMI note the special rules for BLPs", and at the 80th edit you get one that says "BTW biased sources are sometimes okay" (or whichever rules, processes, or misconceptions we think are important enough to send automated messages about).
  4. We could expand RSBIAS to include more information about typical ways for bias to show up (e.g., that it's mainly a sin of omission) and how that's different from the source being factually wrong about the things that it does publish.
  5. We could address biased wording in Wikipedia:Neutral point of view#Impartial tone, e.g., "Write in your own words, using a formal, encyclopedic tone. If a source says "My opponent is a yellow-bellied, black-hearted politician – a man who turns the air blue whenever he speaks, a man who has been caught red-handed performing a green handshake. If you vote for him, we'll soon see his true colors, mostly in the form of the government bleeding red ink and pink slips spreading all over the country", it will often be more appropriate to write 'The other candidate opposed him on grounds of character and economic policies' than to repeat the colorful language."
  6. We could revise Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources so that it has a separate/orthogonal category for being biased, and force RSP voters to vote not only on reliable/complicated/unreliable/deprecated, but also to form a consensus on separate qualities, such as being biased (in which ways?) or being self-published.
  7. Something else?
WhatamIdoing (talk) 04:20, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Noone would read 1 or 2, they don't read the ones that are their now. The fact that the RSN header already contains "Context is important: supply the source, the article it is used in, and the claim it supports." kind of proofs the point.
3 is a good idea, but I wouldn't just limit it to this particular issue. There are many bits of policy or guidance that could be better communicated. Both 4 and 5 would help, as would an explanation that sources only support what they state not what they imply.
I think 6 is just a bad idea, it's one step away from having a column for political leaning, and would just encourage people to discuss bias and think bias is an important factor in reliability.
As a additional point, bias in RS discussions isn't that big an issue. Lack of understanding comes from those who don't know, new editors, or those who won't take it onboard, POV pushers. 4, 5, and particularly 3 would help new editors, nothing will stop POV pushers the will just use anything new to wikilawyer. Instead the more complicated and difficult issue is editors who will use policy and guidance to favour their side. Claiming that the source they don't like is selfpublished so they can use BLPSPS to exclude content they don't like, or that in RSCONTEXT the sources they do like is ok even if the rest of the source is disinformation and propaganda, are far bigger issue than having to tell new editors that bias isn't an issue in reliability per RSBIAS. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 10:46, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
It may be true that no one would read #1, but it wouldn't matter, because one of the experienced editors could cut/pastethe message to NPOVN whether the OP read it or not. WhatamIdoing (talk) 20:06, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
Honestly, we should revise RSP anyway. Structure it so you have information about the source, it's organizational structure, areas of focus, level of editorial control. Things that should be factors on whether or not it is a good source in a particular topic. Instead of right now being a collection of Wikipedia editor's opinions on a source. --Kyohyi (talk) 13:04, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
We're working on it. See Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Restructuring RSP. WhatamIdoing (talk) 20:01, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I find this comment slightly alarming. That discussion is (at least as I understand it and how it is presented) solely about resolving technical issues with RSP; it wouldn't involve any actual changes to its purpose or structure beyond what is needed to resolve the strict technical limitations caused by its size. Kyohyi is obviously suggesting fundamental changes to how RSP works and the information it contains; those two discussions shouldn't be combined or conflated, and obviously no consensus from a discussion premised on "we need to solve a technical limitation" could be used to implement functional changes to what RSP is. --Aquillion (talk) 04:14, 7 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
As far as I'm aware the new structure does contain more information about the source, as each one has its own page. What those pages contain should probably be discussed there, and not at NPOV. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 12:59, 7 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Compare, e.g., Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources/all/PinkNews with the copy of the original table entry at the bottom of that page. We're still at the automated stage, but the main thing now is the addition of an excerpt from the lead of the article, if the source is notable. The main thing for the future is that it will be possible to have more information on the page, if anyone feels like it would be helpful in a given instance. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:05, 7 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Honestly, I find it alarming that someone has an issue with us wanting to have information about the source, it's organizational structure, area of focus, and level of editorial control. --Kyohyi (talk) 14:20, 8 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
It's possible that it could become a site of edit warring or POV pushing, but the proposal was to expand the information that RSP contains, at least to the extent of adding an excerpt from the lead of any publications that we have articles on.
There are some proposals for substantive changes being discussed. For example, the current/old system is to conflate "no consensus" with "other considerations apply", which means that a true case of no consensus is categorized the same as one in which editors have a firm consensus that the most important thing to know about the source is _____ (e.g., that older articles on Quackwatch by its founder are self-published for the purposes of BLP rules). Those two categories will probably get split. However, that's just a prediction from me; there is no decision, because there's not yet been a proper discussion about it. WhatamIdoing (talk) 16:17, 8 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

Anyways!

I propose the following changes:

Attributing and specifying biased statements

Change to Attributing and specifying opinions

Biased statements of opinion.... change to "Statements of opinion..."

Avoid the temptation to rephrase biased or opinion statements... Take out "biased or"

Alternatively, we could change "biased statements" to "opinions from biased sources," but I think that's covered in RS articles. I think the phrase "Biased statements of opinion" is especially confusing, because the policy applies to unbiased opinions. Mevsherd (talk) 14:37, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

Can you give like three examples of articles you've edited, or RFCs you've participated in, where these proposed changes would have made a difference? Levivich (talk) 15:58, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't see any of these as improvements. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 22:44, 28 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

Criticisms

[edit]

What about articles like criticisms of copyright, criticisms of capitalism, criticisms of marriage or any other criticism article, do they need a viewpoint to balance the other viewpoints out. ~2026-51205-16 (talk) 00:56, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

Strictly speaking "criticism" need not mean "negative criticism". But on Wikipedia that ship has probably sailed. Bon courage (talk) 02:49, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
No, see WP:FALSEBALANCE. If reliable sources only present one aspect of criticism towards a topic with no reliable sources defending it, it is inappropriate to push to include that. Masem (t) 11:18, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
That said… on the examples given, there are likely to be reliable sources that rebut the criticisms… and (if so) those should be included. Blueboar (talk) 12:30, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
There can be multiple different forms of criticism on a subject, each would need to be summarised by there weight of reliable sources. For instance capitalism has been criticised from many different ideological and economical stand points. Then any counter points would have to be included, again based on the weight of reliable sources. Just because a page might be titled "Criticism of 'x'" doesn't mean that it has to be wholly negative, only that it discusses the criticism of a subject. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 12:37, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Okay so the goal of “criticism of x” isn’t to show x is bad. It is to discuss the criticisms of x. You are saying that there needs to be other viewpoints Do you think there needs to be a section or sentence addressing this issue such as stating if the article is about discussing a certain viewpoint such as criticisms of x that they don’t necessarily need to be negative but don’t necessarily have to counter opposing viewpoints? ~2026-51205-16 (talk) 17:46, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
No really, it's just a rehash of the first sentence of the policy "representing fairly, proportionately, and, as far as possible, without editorial bias, all the significant views that have been published by reliable sources on a topic." That applies to all article whether have "Criticism of" in the title or not. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 17:56, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
  • Do they need it? No, making it a requirement would be WP:FALSEBALANCE; if the criticisms lack substantial commentary responding to them we shouldn't, like... dig through low-quality sources or perform SYNTH or do anything like that in the name of "balance." But if people disagree and that disagreement gets coverage of comparable weight then we should reflect that weight. Another thing to sometimes consider when making a "criticism of..." article is whether the article itself is DUE; if no response to the criticism exists, but that is because the criticism itself is marginal, it should perhaps be merged into the original article instead. In general, while there are some topics where framing people as "critics" makes sense (for eg. capitalism, where there's plenty of notable authors who wrote from an explicit perspective of critiquing it) one risk of criticism articles or sections is that lumping people in as "critics" can be a form of editorializing, ie. you end up with an overly-supportive main article because anyone who says anything less than fully supportive gets shuffled off to a criticism section or even an entire criticism article. And at the same time it can become a magnet that attracts undue weight to critical views to flesh it out. --Aquillion (talk) 15:42, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

If we wanted to be NPOV we should start by deciding whether or not the article should exist as a separate article. Since they are structurally usually a collection of editor-selected examples of criticisms rather than secondary source coverage of the criticisms. North8000 (talk) 20:04, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

A common tactic: move the UNDUE material into its own article and then nominate it for deletion. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 21:53, 23 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
WP editors do often have the problem of including "trivial" criticism, generally due to some recent event or short-term aspect, alongside actual true criticism. It is human nature to want to document everything "wrong" associated with a topic, and we have to fight the urge to include anything and instead what's best demonstrated in reliable sources. Masem (t) 00:08, 24 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
I saw that in Criticism of Tesco recently. It was mostly a laundry list of anything that appeared in the news, some of it with no particular significance. For example, at one point they hired an external cleaning service; then they had their own employees clean the stores. Some employees thought that cleaning was beneath them and complained to the news. But who actually cares whether the floor was mopped by 'an employee of Tesco' vs 'an employee of a cleaning company'? This has no effect on customers or investors. WhatamIdoing (talk) 13:25, 25 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thats not really criticism it's just trivia. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 16:47, 25 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
"Criticism of ..." articles are generally Wikipedia at its worst. Trivia (yes) dumping grounds. See Criticism of Walmart. The racist wig is perhaps the lowest point. Bon courage (talk) 16:52, 25 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
One of my points is that criticism articles are structurally different than most articles. Most articles are providing sourced information about the topic of the article. Most criticism articles aren't. Instead they are a wiki-editor compilation of examples of criticisms, not secondary source coverage of the criticism(s). This gives a license to (coatrack for) the Wiki-editor to create any compilation that they care to. Not saying that we shouldn't have these, but there should be scrutiny on when that license should be granted. North8000 (talk) 19:39, 24 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

BALASP on what should be included

[edit]

@Danbloch, you've reverted this information twice. Please read the discussion that resulted in it being added, which is at Wikipedia talk:Neutral point of view/Archive 68#BALASP and writing an encyclopedia article. Then please explain why you think that a statement that certain information should be included to make an article neutral has no place in the policy on what makes an article neutral, and/or why you think that a statement about what to include has no relationship to a section on what to include and exclude.

For reference, the two paragraphs in BALASP before your reversions were: (1) things to exclude unless they are emphasized in sources, and (2) things to include even if they aren't emphasized in sources. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:05, 4 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

The two paragraphs in question are:

An article should not give undue weight to minor aspects of its subject but should strive to treat each aspect with a weight proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject. For example, a description of isolated events, quotes, criticisms, or news reports related to one subject may be verifiable and impartial, but still disproportionate to their overall significance to the article topic. This is a concern especially for recent events that may be in the news.

In addition to describing why the subject is notable (e.g., "is an author", "biggest employer in the region"), neutral encyclopedia articles should place the subject in context. For example, an article about a person should always indicate, at least in a general way, when and where they lived (e.g., "17th-century Spanish writer", "born c. 1907 in Japan"), and an article about a business should always indicate the nature of its business (e.g., "manufactures widgets", "shipping and logistics company").

The first of these paragraphs is the long-standing WP:BALASP. The second is the one which you added and I removed.
This topic is covered in Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Lead section (The lead should stand on its own as a concise overview of the article's topic. It should identify the topic, establish context, explain why the topic is notable, and summarize the most important points, including any prominent controversies.) If you want to add an example, please add it there. Again, it has nothing to do with neutrality. Danbloch (talk) 07:05, 5 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I should also mention, I did read the talk page discussion, thanks, and it didn't have an explanation for why the paragraph was related to neutrality. It just proposed adding the paragraph, and there was general agreement that context was important, but nothing about its relevance to neutrality. Danbloch (talk) 07:45, 5 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Here's the problem we're trying to solve:
  • Editors are accustomed to deciding what belongs in an article based on how much attention the sources pay to it. (This is good.)
  • But some times, there is information that is only mentioned by sources in passing. It is important information, but it doesn't require a lot of words to discuss it, or the implications are so obvious that the sources don't bother explaining. However, if you omit that, you have not written a neutral article. You have instead written a biased article (←the main subject of this page). And you have probably not written an encyclopedia article (←the subject of this page, as well as many other pages).
For example, a scholarly source about an antibiotic might not spend a lot of time explaining that antibiotics kill bacteria, or it might contain just the one word antibiotic about that fact. If you give it "a weight proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject", then the Wikipedia article should not mention that at all, or should give it no more than one word. But that wouldn't be a neutral description, as in, it wouldn't fairly address this key fact.
Similarly, if you are writing about a subject in some obvious situation (e.g., royalty, enslaved, disabled), your source may only mention this in passing. It's so obvious that this artist was the phenomenally wealthy younger prince that the source skips lightly over that, but Wikipedia shouldn't. The balance of the royal family aspect vs artistic aspect that is reasonable for the source is not a neutral balance of these aspects for an encyclopedia article.
As a simplistic example of the problem, the world has very few sources explaining why someone's birth date is important (and most of those are unreliable astrology sources). We don't have much, if any, "reliable, published material on the subject" about their birth date. Sometimes we are scrounging for the weakest of sources, such as a self-published, non-independent social media post. And yet editors believe that omitting this information is wrong. It's not wrong because it's a stylistic problem; it's wrong because it presents the person in a non-neutral, biased light. If you were trying to give "a weight proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject", then we should have almost no birth dates in any article, and we wouldn't have birth years or birth places in most biographies. And yet we do, and we even set up whole categories to find and track people this way. This is because placing the subject in this kind of context is more important for an encyclopedia than it can be seen based on "its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject". In other words, "its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject" is not a reliable path to a neutral article for basic contextual information. BALASP's recommendation to have a Wikipedia article's content be "proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject" does not apply to 100% of ordinary article content. WhatamIdoing (talk) 17:04, 5 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Would a worked example help?

Source Matching the source Neutral article
Bob's Big Business, Inc. of Smallville was sued again today for groundwater pollution by by Eve Environmentalist's Smallville Eco Coalition. This lawsuit alleges that a leaking pipe has leached blue dye into the ground water.  A photo shows blue liquid and a video of a maintenance employee mopping it up with ordinary equipment.  In response, Bob said, "Would someone please tell Eve that I'm sorry I didn't ask her to the homecoming dance, but that was 20 years ago, and she needs to get over it.  There was no leaking pipe.  The so-called puddle of industrial waste was just a melted blue raspberry Slurpee from 7-Eleven that someone spilled on the public sidewalk.  I sent someone out to clean it up so nobody would slip and fall on it."

The company has been the target of the SEC's ire since the main factory was built.  "If Bob didn't want to be sued, then he shouldn't have built his factory next to my garden.  The zinnias have never been the same since.  They need a lot of sunlight, you know", said Eve.  "And how do we know that it was just a drink?  Besides, food dyes cause cancer, and it's the exact same color of blue as the light blue widgets the company manufactures.  That factory is a public nuisance."  

The SEC, whose main members are Eve and her best friend, meets every Thursday for coffee and to drum up ideas about how to oppose the business.  Their previous efforts have included parading up and down in front of the factory while wearing costumes, at least 16 lawsuits, all of which were dismissed, an annual ugliest dog competition, and, once, a sparsely attended sing-a-long.  The steady stream of lawsuits and protests have had a positive effect on Smallville's economy, resulting in at least three new subscriptions to this newspaper.  "It's better than the funny page", said one subscriber.  The effect on the business is less certain.  Sources indicate that Bob's uncle, an irascible old-school retired lawyer, handles the lawsuits for free, but observers have suggested that they may deter some investors.

Bob's Big Business is a business that has been sued by local environmentalists 16 times, including for allegedly leaking blue dye into the ground water and blocking light to neighboring property. The business denies that any leak happened. Additionally, the business has been the target of many local protests. Bob's Big Business is a widget manufacturer in Smallville.

A small group of local protestors has opposed them.

Editors should consider what the correct balance of different aspects is, and this should be based on the sources, but there are limits to this. A perfect replication of the balance in the sources is not the goal. The goal is to provide some minimal level of basic contextual information (What kind of a business? Where are they?) and to replicate the balance of different aspects found in the sources only to the extent that doing so would produce an appropriate encyclopedia article. If we followed the first paragraph of BALASP rigidly, we'd end up with articles that are unencyclopedic and non-neutral (e.g., violate WP:NOTGOSSIP). Therefore the first paragraph needs the counterweight of the second paragraph: Yes, follow the sources. But don't follow them so far that they would result in tabloid content instead of an encyclopedia article. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:08, 5 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

I would be inclined to think that the issue in cases such as the one described here is not so much following the balance in the sources too rigidly, but assessing it incorrectly—typically, basic contextual information will be present in the overall body of sources on a given topic to an extent that would justify inclusion. Anyway, assuming that the disputed paragraph should be included in the WP:Neutral point of view policy in the first place, I don't think the "Balancing aspects" section is where it should be—it's rather out of place under that heading and going from the preceding paragraph to that one is very awkward. I might instead suggest adding a new heading along the lines of "Providing necessary context" below the "Making necessary assumptions" section, perhaps. TompaDompa (talk) 20:43, 5 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree with everything TompaDompa said. I'm still not convinced that this belongs here instead of MOS:LEAD, but if it were broken out into its own section with a clear title, per TompaDompa, so it didn't impede the flow of reading the article, I wouldn't object to it.
I do have one question regardless. This feels like a theoretical problem. Has it ever actually happened? (Editors omitting significant context because it has too few mentions?) Danbloch (talk) 00:35, 6 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Yes, it happens.
The disputes often involve someone who has a strong personal belief about what 'shouldn't' be in an encyclopedia article: People shouldn't care about the subject's nationality, so let's leave that out. People shouldn't care about the subject's birth date, so let's leave that out. Look, it's only briefly mentioned in one reliable source, so you can't claim that it's "DUE"!
IMO the more important problem is the non-neutral focus on whatever negative/disparaging content is in the news today. You don't need to know that he's an actor; you only need to know he's accused of sexual harassment. You don't need to know that the company makes widgets; you only need to know that they're being sued for wage theft. You don't need to know what the professor's research area is; you only need to know that he's accused of plagiarism. You don't need to know what the altmed thing is; you only need to know that it's ineffective pseudoscience. And so forth.
We might need an article that is mainly about harassment/lawsuits/plagiarism/pseudoscience/whatever. I'm willing to call a spade a spade, and even to call a criminal a criminal, despite the best efforts of several editors to convince me otherwise. However, we still need to include that basic contextual information. If we don't, we have not produced a neutral encyclopedia article.
On the other points:
  • This isn't just about the lead. It's definitely not just about the MOS:FIRST sentence. Sure, we joke about FTN editors wanting to write something like "Homeopathy is ineffective pseudoscience that doesn't work" for the first sentence of Homeopathy, but this affects the whole article. WP:LEADFOLLOWSBODY, and if you get the body wrong, you'll get the lead wrong, too.
  • This isn't about writing style. It is not a MOS issue. This is about what to include, as in WP:NPOV#What to include and exclude. It is about the facts themselves ("Do we include her husband's name at all?"), rather than being about various ways to express those facts ("Since we've already decided to include her husband's name, do we put it in the infobox, in the lead, or in the ==Personal life== section?").
  • I don't think it should be a separate section. This is a BALASP issue. Paragraph 1 says to include the facts (as opposed to viewpoints, which is the DUE section) in proportion to their appearance in reliable sources. Paragraph 2 adds some limits to Paragraph 1 (namely that editors should not blindly follow the sources right down into the gutter).
I would like to better understand how this paragraph could "impede the flow of reading the article". Much of the policy needs a good copyedit (we rearranged a couple of years ago, with the explicit understanding that we'd not change the wording until folks had gotten used to the new order), but I don't feel like this impedes the flow. WhatamIdoing (talk) 01:28, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
The advice boils down to "basic contextual information needs to be included". No argument there. It is however not a question of balancing aspects, because it isn't about the balance between different aspects. It is a question of including a minimum of basic information that needs to be there for its own sake, regardless of the coverage of other aspects. Hence, out of place in the "Balancing aspects" section. In a way, it can be thought of as the flip side to "Making necessary assumptions", which would make framing it as "Providing necessary context" a logical approach. I can't say I understand why putting it under the heading "Providing necessary context" should not be satisfactory to everyone.
As for impeding the flow, I can only speak for myself, but I think the second paragraph does not follow naturally from the first at all. For instance, going from not over-emphasizing minor aspects to "In addition to describing why the subject is notable [...]" is odd to me—when did we start talking about notability? The two paragraphs seem like they are about completely different things and were written for completely different purposes at completely different times, perhaps by completely different people. Even knowing that the intention is for the second paragraph to temper/be a limitation on the first, I find it difficult to parse it as anything other than a non sequitur in the context in which it is presented. There's nothing necessarily wrong with the paragraph itself, but it doesn't seem to fit with the preceding one. TompaDompa (talk) 02:25, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Do we agree that "balancing aspects" is something like this?
  • 75% of the sources are about the former child star's acting career, and 25% of the sources are about the former child star's personal life as an adult.
  • Therefore, 75% of the Wikipedia article should be about the former child star's acting career, and 25% of the Wikipedia article should be about the former child star's personal life as an adult.
WhatamIdoing (talk) 03:05, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
No, and I don't think this is a helpful tangent to go off on. TompaDompa (talk) 03:23, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
BALASP says that editors should give different aspects "a weight proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject".
"Acting career" and "Personal life" are the "aspects" in my example. "75%" and "25%" are "proportions".
What do you think that long-standing sentence means, if it doesn't mean to spend more of the article talking about what the sources spend more time talking about, and proportionately less about the things that they spend less time talking about? WhatamIdoing (talk) 06:10, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't think number of sources is sufficient to look at, either in the context of giving due weight to aspects (WP:PROPORTION) or viewpoints (WP:DUE). Nor do I think word count in the sources is. I would be surprised if any sizeable proportion of experienced editors think such a thoroughly quantitative approach is the most appropriate. But this is, as I said, a tangent.
I am not convinced the paragraph under discussion needs to be here in the first place. I don't think that is likely to change with further discussion.
I think the paragraph sticks out like a sore thumb in the "Balancing aspects" section. I don't think that is likely to change with further discussion.
I would not mind it being included under a new heading of "Providing necessary context". Danbloch appears to agree.
I would rather not engage in further lengthy discussion that is unlikely to reach a different conclusion when we have a perfectly cromulent alternative that as far as I can tell should be mutually satisfactory. TompaDompa (talk) 11:22, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
This is not a tangent.
The first paragraph says: "An article should not give undue weight to minor aspects of its subject but should strive to treat each aspect with a weight proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject".
You say that editors should not actually care about the Proportion (mathematics) of the aspects treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject, even though the policy says that they should use that proportion to determine the article content.
How would you tell them what they should do, if the mathematical language isn't appropriate? WhatamIdoing (talk) 23:18, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
No, that's not what I said—I said that it is not sufficient to look at the either of the two specific quantitative metrics I mentioned. And no, the policy does not say that—it says a weight proportional to its treatment.
Is there any particular reason putting the paragraph under a new heading of "Providing necessary context" should not be acceptable to you? I recognize that you would prefer having it under the existing "Balancing aspects" heading, but would a new section be a worse option than omitting it entirely? TompaDompa (talk) 23:39, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
If it's not sufficient to consider the proportion of aspects as presented in the sources (which is fundamentally quantitative, but not necessarily on the basis of "number of sources" or "word count"), what else do you think editors should be considering?
I think they should be considering the necessity of providing a basic identification of the subject ("is an author") and placing that subject in context ("who was born c. 1907 in Japan"). That's why I proposed that paragraph specifically for BALASP: you should follow the proportions in the sources, but also leave room for basic identification and context. Yes, proportion. But proportion alone is not sufficient.
Do you think they should not leave room for basic identification and context? And if you don't, what would you add? And why not put it in the same section as the one that says "proportion alone!", since the point is to say that proportion alone is not sufficient? WhatamIdoing (talk) 23:48, 7 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
The thing is that neither the proportion of aspects nor the proportions in the sources is something the policy discusses. It says that each aspect should be given a weight proportional to its treatment in the sources. The weight should be proportional to the treatment—the weight in our article should be proportional to the treatment in the sources. Do you see the difference?
The weight in our article is not a purely quantitative thing—as is acknowledged by the policy itself (Undue weight can be given in several ways, including but not limited to the depth of detail, quantity of text, prominence of placement, juxtaposition of statements, and use of imagery.). Likewise, the treatment in the sources is not a purely quantitative thing.
I have already explained that I don't share your view of what the likely problem is in the hypothetical situations you describe, nor do I share your view of how the paragraph fits in the context it was presented. In the interest of moving forward, and in the absence of anybody expressing a clear preference for omitting the paragraph entirely rather than presenting it in a separate section (the comment I don't think it should be a separate section. This is a BALASP issue. is duly noted), I'll add it under the heading "Providing necessary context". If I have misunderstood your position and you do indeed think omitting it entirely is the preferable alternative, feel free to remove it. Otherwise, I think it would be a good idea for the two of us to leave it at that lest we end up inadvertently more-or-less sealioning each other through further back-and-forth. TompaDompa (talk) 00:38, 8 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Is there any evidence that including basic info about a subject ("17th-century Spanish philosopher," "shipping and logistics company") is causing any sort of conflict or problem w/r/t WP:NPOV? Are people arguing about whether or not to include such details and citing NPOV in their arguments? Unless the current policy is causing confusion on this, I don't think it needs to be said here, per WP:CREEP. Also, I worry that "'far-left/right' is necessary context even if only a few sources say it!" will become a common argument if we make "necessary context" some sort of exception to NPOV (DUE/PROPORTION). Levivich (talk) 20:22, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think that's a fair point about the risk of arguments about whether XYZ is necessary context. For the record, the disputed paragraph is currently included in the policy as a stand-alone section (Wikipedia:Neutral point of view#Providing necessary context). TompaDompa (talk) 21:19, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think that, as a core content policy, it's appropriate to provide general information about what editors should do. I don't think it needs to include creepy details, but there should be something in this policy that says (e.g.,) ephemeral gossip is out, and basic demographic information is in. WhatamIdoing (talk) 01:46, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Combining WP:PROPORTION and WP:DUE

[edit]

It is extremely common for editors to cite WP:DUE/WP:UNDUE (a.k.a. WP:WEIGHT) when they actually mean WP:PROPORTION (a.k.a. WP:ASPECT and WP:BALASP). The difference is that WP:DUE covers "viewpoints", where as WP:PROPORTION covers "aspects" (a.k.a. details that are not viewpoints). WP:PROPORTION says the same thing that WP:DUE says, it just says it about "aspects" instead of "viewpoints." Both WP:PROPORTION and WP:DUE are subsections of WP:NPOV § What to include and exclude, but I don't think we need two separate subsections -- one for viewpoints and one for other aspects -- and anyway everybody tend to just call it "WP:DUE" rather than distinguish between WP:DUE and WP:ASPECT. Anybody besides me think we should just have one subsection on this, and merge WP:PROPORTION into WP:DUE, and just say something like "viewpoint or other aspect"? Levivich (talk) 18:28, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

I think that keeping them separate is better, because there's one key difference in how they should be handled:
  • 'Viewpoints' should be handled in proportion to the sources: If most scholars believe "X", and some scholars believe "Y", then the Wikipedia article should present "X" as the most common view and "Y" as a significant minority.
  • 'Aspects' should be handled in proportion to the sources, but with our own editorial thumb on the scale, because we need an encyclopedia article instead of (depending on the subject in question) a gossip magazine, a debating forum, a how-to manual, etc.
PROPORTION currently "says the same thing that WP:DUE says", but that's only because the paragraph differentiating the two was removed last week. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:59, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I don't see anything in WP:PROPORTION that says "with our own editorial thumb on the scale". WP:PROPORTION is small enough to quote here:

An article should not give undue weight to minor aspects of its subject but should strive to treat each aspect with a weight proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject. For example, a description of isolated events, quotes, criticisms, or news reports related to one subject may be verifiable and impartial, but still disproportionate to their overall significance to the article topic. This is a concern especially for recent events that may be in the news.

There is nothing there about editors putting a thumb on the scale, it says "with a weight proportional to its treatment in the body of reliable, published material on the subject", which is the same as what WP:DUE says ("fairly represent all significant viewpoints that have been published by reliable sources, in proportion to the prominence of each viewpoint in those sources").
As to the recently-removed second paragraph, I also don't see anything there that says anything about editors putting thumbs on scales or otherwise distinguished between WP:PROPORTION and WP:DUE. That second paragraph said:

In addition to describing why the subject is notable (e.g., "is an author", "biggest employer in the region"), encyclopedia articles should place the subject in context. For example, an article about a person should always indicate, at least in a general way, when and where they lived (e.g., "17th-century Spanish writer", "born c. 1907 in Japan"), and an article about a business should always indicate the nature of its business (e.g., "manufactures widgets", "shipping and logistics company").

I agree with the removal of the paragraph, it seems superfluous, giving two examples of details that would meet the tests of WP:PROPORTION or WP:DUE. Reliable sources about a person are going to say when and where the person lived (e.g., "17-century Spanish writer"), and reliable sources about a company are going to say the nature of its business (e.g., "manufactures widgets").
Both WP:PROPORTION (before and after the removal of the second paragraph) and WP:DUE say, essentially, "follow the sources," include viewpoints/details in proportion to their coverage by the sources. Levivich (talk) 19:15, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think the removed second paragraph is saying that, even if reliable sources barely mention where and when they lived or what the nature of their business is, this is necessary context that should always be included in an encyclopaedia article, which seems to me like something the policy should say.
As for the merge proposal, I'm not seeing any benefit to keeping them separate (merging the above sentence if it is restored) as they're talking about essentially the same thing from just very slightly different aspects and very few people even make the distinction in practice. Thryduulf (talk) 19:53, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Ah. I just realized the second paragraph was only added in February and is being discussed in the thread above. I think the inclusion of that language is a separate issue from whether the two sections should be merged; it can be included (or not) regardless of whether the sections are merged or not. Levivich (talk) 20:15, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
We rearranged the whole policy a couple of years ago, and there is some work that needs to be done as a result. At the time, the decision was to let it settle for a bit, and come back to it after editors had had time to get used to the new structure. I've no objection to doing that work in principle. I'm just not convinced that this is a change that should be made. WhatamIdoing (talk) 01:41, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I would think the way it is currently with these sections separate is not broken, and so not in need of fixing. The way I like to put it is that "X is worth mentioning" is a viewpoint, as is of course "Y is not worth mentioning"; however, not everyone thinks about it that way and it seems useful to me to have WP:PROPORTION to point to where it is spelled out as explicitly as it is, and without any risk of it being "lost in the shuffle", so to speak. Generally speaking, my view is that policy and guidelines should ideally be written in a way that allows excerpts to be quoted and the meaning understood without requiring the context of the surrounding text (or indeed some other text, which may be located somewhere else entirely), and I think the current version serves that function well. TompaDompa (talk) 21:42, 10 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
"X is worth mentioning in this Wikipedia article" is not a viewpoint within the limits of this policy. It is an editorial decision to be made by Wikipedia editors, rather than something to defer entirely to the sources. The reliable sources get to decide whether something is properly considered a Moon landing hoax; Wikipedia editors get to decide whether gossip belongs in an article about a BLP (even if that's all that's been in the news about that person for the last year), or whether instructions belong in an article about a technical subject (even if nearly all the sources ever published are about how to correctly install it). WhatamIdoing (talk) 01:39, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
"X is worth mentioning in this Wikipedia article" is not what I'm talking about. Sources mentioning X reflects their viewpoint that X is worth mentioning, and sources not mentioning Y reflects their viewpoint that Y is not worth mentioning. TompaDompa (talk) 08:41, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
"X is worth mentioning in this Wikipedia article" is what BALASP/PROPORTION is talking about. WhatamIdoing (talk) 22:28, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
That is, for lack of a better term, the output of the policy. The viewpoints in the sources is the input. The output (what is included in the Wikipedia article on a particular topic) is supposed to reflect the input (what is included in the sources on that topic). The WP:Neutral point of view policy concerns viewpoints, so why would facts—the balance of aspects—enter into it? Well, because which facts are considered worth mentioning (and how) is a viewpoint. For example: "Oskar Schindler was a member of the Nazi Party" and "Oskar Schindler is credited with saving the lives of more than a thousand Jews during the Holocaust" are both statements of fact, but the former is treated as a relatively minor point by the sources while the latter is treated as a very important thing indeed, and so over-emphasizing the former would not be reflecting the sources in that regard and thus non-neutral. TompaDompa (talk) 07:20, 12 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
The first example you give is a fact, rather than a viewpoint. I agree that a decent article would not over-emphasize the former fact.
However, the scenarios that BALASP needs to address are these:
  • We have seven articles that say Bob's Big Business, Inc. made its annual donation to support the local youth sports. Also, one article about a lawsuit about unsafe working conditions and two about developing a new widget process.
    • If editors are supposed to only "reflect the input", then most of the sources find the youth sports donations more worthy of writing about than the other subjects. Should the Wikipedia article therefore be 70% about youth sports donations, since 70% of the sources are about this? One-third, since it's one of three main reasons the company is written about? Or almost none [←my vote]? And if that last one, then how can we possibly claim that writing almost nothing about what the sources write the most about "reflects the input" of the sources?
  • We have almost no sources on the CEO's background or family life. And yet it is normal for an encyclopedia article about a person to contain information about where and when the person lived, how they were educated, and what their family background is.
    • If editors are supposed to only "reflect the input", should we omit this normal, encyclopedic content? Or should we put in whatever little bits we can verify (e.g., citing Bob's own social media post for his birthday), because encyclopedias include that content, even though non-encyclopedia sources don't?
WhatamIdoing (talk) 03:44, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Why does WP:BALASP, specifically, need to address those scenarios? That does not seem self-evident to me. We have several other policies and guidelines that work in tandem. WP:NOT, for instance. The way you are framing it, it seems to me to be a lot more about what would be encyclopedic than what would be neutral. TompaDompa (talk) 12:03, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Because when editors get the WP:PROPORTION wrong, the result is a non-neutral article. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:58, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
And when they include non-encyclopaedic content, the result is a non-encyclopaedic article. If your contention is that certain kinds of information are inherently not encyclopaedic, that is under the purview of WP:What Wikipedia is not. Your assertion that this is a neutrality issue seems circular to me, or perhaps predicated on some assumption not clearly stated. TompaDompa (talk) 23:48, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
I think this stretches "viewpoint" so far as to be unhelpful. Katzrockso (talk) 03:29, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Sometimes. Not mentioning Y can reflect a deliberate consideration by the author of the RS that Y is not important (signal, for our purposes), but it could also reflect whimsy, accident, writing for an audience other than that of a general encyclopedia, and so on (noise). By considering "the body of reliable, published material on the subject" (PROPORTION) or "prevalence in reliable sources" (DUE; is that implied to be all reliable sources?), we hope, as in statistics, to make these errors cancel each other and accurately estimate what we should and shouldn't write about the subject. This also points to the case where a rigid, prescriptive application of the policies will break down: when the body of material on a subject is a very small one, it is easier for caprice in the reliable sources to cause over- or under-emphasis of a point, compared to actual expert opinion. Choess (talk) 06:08, 12 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
That all seems uncontroversial to me. As always, we are limited to what sources are available to us. TompaDompa (talk) 07:20, 12 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
We are limited to what sources are available in one direction (e.g., we can't include a birth date, because as far as we can tell, it's never been published).
We are not limited in the other direction (e.g., we've got multiple magazine articles detailing what Chris Celebrity wore on the ides of March this year). And yet we shouldn't include that information, or should only include it in a way that is much more limited than its prevalence in the body of reliable sources, per BALASP. WhatamIdoing (talk) 03:33, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Prevalence and treatment not being the same thing notwithstanding, the second part of what you are saying does not seem uncontroversial to me. At least, not in a way that lends itself to a concise and helpful guidance for inclusion here—there are plenty of different types of information and situations where editors might reasonably disagree whether to apply this kind of thinking or not. WP:NOT is fairly lengthy, and for good reason. TompaDompa (talk) 12:03, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Yes, and yet if the majority of a BLP on Chris Celebrity were to be about their red carpet outfit, then we'd slap one of the Category:Neutrality templates on it, because it would not have the right WP:PROPORTION of information about fashion choices vs other content. WhatamIdoing (talk) 18:57, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Such an extreme example would obviously be a violation of WP:PROPORTION as currently written—and for that matter WP:NOTGOSSIP. It is not clear to me what you think should change here. Based on the hypotheticals you bring up, you seem to think certain kinds of information should be given greater consideration than others. I am inclined to agree at that broad level (though we may perhaps disagree strongly on the specifics), but it is of course a far cry from anything that is useful guidance in practice, and I am not convinced it can be turned into that. I am also not convinced that this is best thought of as primarily an issue of neutrality, rather than e.g. one of encyclopaedicity. Have you an actionable suggestion about a way you think the policy should be altered that may be discussed more concretely? TompaDompa (talk) 23:48, 13 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
What is useful is to give editors a sentence to quote when the dispute comes up, and someone says "All the sources are saying _____ about this subject, so only content about _____ should be in the Wikipedia article." PROPORTION has a statement saying that it's disproportionate to include some verifiable information. PROPORTION needs the statement that says it's also disproportionate to exclude some verifiable information. WhatamIdoing (talk) 00:52, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Hm, maybe. Sounds like it might be redundant to WP:Neutral point of view#Providing necessary context, depending on what it would say. Did you have any particular phrasing in mind? TompaDompa (talk) 01:43, 15 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
It's true that editors often say WP:DUE when they mean WP:BALASP, but for those who do appreciate the difference it allows for clearer communication (including when talking to people who may not have been aware of the BALASP provision). I also see that when the aspects text was first added (in 2006) it was part of the WP:DUE section, so at some point a conscious decision was made to split it out.
I don't see a compelling reason to take the distinction away. Danbloch (talk) 05:17, 11 November 2026 (UTC)Reply